luxury houses for rent Sag Harbor, United States

Nestled in the quiet community of Bay Point, this 3-bedroom, 3-bath summer residence offers a refined coastal experience near Long Beach-the best bay beach in the Hamptons! The front door is centered by a classic rose trellis, and the lushly landscaped grounds feature a 16x38 heated gunite saltwater pool, a 900 sq ft Bluestone patio and convenient outdoor shower. While the grounds are intimate, they are meticulously planted to ensure a secluded and luxurious atmosphere. Upstairs, the primary bedroom and ensuite guest bedroom give everybody privacy, while the main level offers room to spread out with plenty of access to the pool area and backyard. Order grocery delivery, and you'll never have to leave! [[Rental Registration # Pending]] Rental Terms: July - Labor Day: $120,000

Built in 1830 and painstakingly restored/renovated in 2013, this 3,000 sf, 4 bedroom, 3 bath home in the heart of Sag Harbor Village offers a beautiful living room, formal dining room and wonderful, fully-equipped chef's kitchen. French doors from the kitchen lead to the elegant and expansive gardens and landscape designed by a renown architect, heated salt water pool and pool house to lounge in with a pull out sofa, TV & full bath. This historic home is perfection, as is the location...2 minutes to Main Street! Rental Terms: July - Labor Day: $175,000 July: $85,000 August - Labor Day: $95,000

Set on a substantial .35-acre lot, the fully- fenced backyard features a gunite pool, pool shed, and patio that is perfect for outdoor dining and entertaining. Inside offers tremendous versatility. The first floor has an open floorplan with renovated kitchen and bathrooms. There is a first floor bedroom plus 2 bedrooms upstairs. The location offers a fantastic lifestyle, 0.7 Miles to Main Street, with a couple dozen high-end restaurants and bars, boutique shops, and renowned Bay Street Theater and Sag Harbor Cinema. The homes upgraded amenities include Central A/C and Central Vac. Rental Terms: Other / Short Term - Year Round: $78,000 Winter Season: $25,000 Per Month Memorial Day - Labor Day: $50,000

Totally renovated with the finest historic details, offering spacious, light-filled double parlors, a grand chef's entertaining kitchen fully opens to an expansive porch with built in heating for chilly nights, a private dining patio, gunite pool, spa, poolhouse bar, powder room & outdoor grotto shower. Three floors offer 5+ bedrooms, 7 baths, luxe library, butler's pantry, 7 fireplaces, viewing balcony decks on the 2nd floor. Perfect entertaining home in the heart of Sag Harbor village, close to theater, restaurants and marina. [[Rental Registration # landlordrequested]] EH RR #: landlord requested Rental Terms: Other / Short Term - Year Round: $550,000 July - Labor Day: $285,000 Winter Season: $270,000 Per Month Memorial Day - Labor Day: $325,000

Experience luxury living in this newly constructed North Haven modern estate, set on 3.25 acres with breathtaking harbor views. Interior design by the renowned Melanie Roy, this estate offers a state-of-the-art chef's kitchen with a dining area overlooking the water, two stunning living rooms, and a second primary bedroom on the main level. The grand entrance is spectacular, featuring a floating staircase and an elevator. Outside, enjoy a 20x50 waterside saltwater heated gunite pool and jet spa, a spacious lounge area with magnificent views, and a path leading to the water for paddle boarding and kayaking. The property also includes a detached studio/office/yoga room with a full bath and an electric screened-in porch with panoramic waterfront views. The second level boasts four spacious ensuite bedrooms, including a grand primary suite, all with terraces and beautiful vistas. The lower level is perfect for entertainment with a large flatscreen TV, sound system, a game room with a pool table, an additional full bedroom with bath, a gym, and a 5-person sauna. With a 3-car garage and ample parking in the front courtyard, North Haven Manor also offers resident pathways to the beach and open water. Boat mooring is available, also great for kayaking and paddle boarding. Located just minutes from the village of Sag Harbor, this premier rental listing is available for THE US OPEN in JUNE, offered exclusively through Sotheby's International Realty. [[Rental Registration # R-2025-0006]] EH RR #: R-2025-0006 Rental Terms: June: $150,000 July: $375,000

This Sag Harbor home offers a unique opportunity to be able to vacation in a beautifully renovated and tastefully decorated home in the middle of all the action - boating, dining, theater, shopping, swimming. This three-level home takes full advantage of the water views with a living area and wet bar on the third floor. The chef's kitchen flows seamlessly into both indoor & outdoor dining options - great for entertaining. All of the bedrooms have access to a private bathroom - two bedrooms are en-suite. The fourth bedroom is being used as a third-floor lounge area and has a pull out couch for guests. The lower level is fully finished and offers a cozy space for rainy days and functions well as a home office with natural light and walk-out access to the backyard garden. There is a full bathroom and laundry on the lower level as well. Rental Terms: September: $40,000

A stylish, gorgeous construction designed by award-winning architect James Merril. Set on an acre, this 5- 5-bedroom home has every desirable amenity. The primary bedroom has a terrace and a beautiful bathroom with a shower and a separate bathtub. The 4 guest rooms are all spacious and light-filled. Downstairs, there is an open living room and a den/ 5th bedroom with a full bath. An exquisite gourmet kitchen has all the bells and whistles, from a 6-burner Viking with a grill to a double Sub-Zero Fridge, wine fridge, double sinks, and dishwashers; it also has its own breakfast area. There is a formal dining area with a fireplace that is magnificent. The sunny Living Room shares the same dual-sided open fireplace. A lower-level gym. Many French doors open to the deck that has a gorgeous outdoor dining area- and a shaded lounge area with a 32' by 15' ft. heated pool. A path to the dock on the bay, which is a divine protected sanctuary, that accesses the big open bay. There is a lower basement level with a 2-car garage. The front of the house has a great veranda, all set on a quiet and charming high-end street in the Village of Sag Harbor. Rental Terms: Other / Short Term - Year Round: $450,000 Memorial Day - Labor Day: $375,000 September: $25,000 July - Labor Day: $300,000 October: $25,000 November: $20,000 June: $60,000

5BR/ 6.5 BA w/ Tennis on 5 + acres with Pool, Hot Tub, Sauna & Basket Ball Court! Open plan living / dining room / Kitchen and so much more! Escape Out East to Sag Harbor! Live the good life on this remarkable, 5.4 acre gated compound. There's no doubt you'll fall in love with the Hamptons, as you enjoy a peaceful stay at this private retreat! This stunning contemporary home sleeps 12, with five en-suite bedrooms, including three primary suites, one on the first level with a sauna and a private deck. The sun-filled open concept living room features a cathedral ceiling, skylights, a gas-burning fireplace, and an open dining room with French doors leading to a covered porch. The spectacular state of the art kitchen features Subzero and Wolf appliances as well as a miele and nespresso machines. Additional highlights include a fully finished lower level with ping pong and pool tables, tennis ball machine office set up and an additional queen pull out bed. You and your guests will love the convenience of the 7 smart TVs, 5 separate Sonos zones inside and a 6th outside, the Mesh wifi system (gigabyte internet) by Optimum, and the Samsung dryer and washer. In the sun-filled study guests will find a fully functioning office setup complete with a laser printer and IMac computer. Additional features include top of the line mattresses on each of the beds, a peloton bike and brand new furniture throughout. The north wing master suite features a wood burning fireplace, a private study, a jacuzzi tub and a double shower. In the south wing primary suite, you will find 20 foot ceilings, a surround sound system, an additional gas burning fireplace, soaking tub and a double rain head shower. Step outside for some fresh air and enjoy beautiful views of the large grounds featuring a heated gunite pool plus a 10 seat hot tub, a new secluded and lighted tennis court, with separate covered entertaining space as well as a fire pit area. Guests can enjoy the use of adult and children's bicycles, beach chairs, a paddleboard and even a kayak. The home is surrounded by miles of nature preserve trail systems and private ponds to discover. Prepare to fall in love with the Hamptons lifestyle, as you experience it at its very best! This property is a 5 minute drive to Sag Harbor's Main Street and 7 minutes to East Hampton. [[Rental Registration # RR-25-1159]] EH RR #: RR-25-1159 Rental Terms: Other / Short Term - Year Round: $500,000 Memorial Day - Labor Day: $295,000 July - Labor Day: $225,000 July: $125,000 June: $85,000 August - Labor Day: $135,000

Located on a quiet street around the corner from a private bay beach, and short walk, ride or drive to the village, this light-filled, minimalist, stylish home offers the perfect choice for your summer getaway. With 3 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms, the house offers ample space for families. The main floor includes a guest bedroom and bathroom, while the upper floor hosts the primary suite and an additional guest bedroom and bathroom. The chef's kitchen features stainless steel appliances, a massive island and dining table for entertaining and family meals. The deck overlooks manicured grounds, perfect for outdoor entertaining and morning coffee listening to birdsong. The lower level provides a TV lounge, air hockey table, a laundry facility, and an extra bathroom for added convenience. Whether you're planning a peaceful retreat or an active vacation, this home serves as the ultimate base for all your vacation plans and village fun. Available June 25th to Sept 7th. $50,000 [[Rental Registration # inprogress]] EH RR #: R-25-0006 Rental Terms: August - Labor Day: $35,000

Discover the perfect Fall getaway in this stunning artist's home in Sag Harbor, now available from Sept 8th - Oct 5th 2026. Ideally situated between Sag Harbor Village and Long Beach, this immaculate 4-bedroom, 3.5-bathroom residence is a true oasis, featuring a well-curated collection of art within a sophisticated monochromatic interior. Built in 2018, this contemporary farmhouse beautifully balances exceptional style and comfort. An open-plan kitchen, dining, and living area seamlessly transitions to the 32' x 16' heated gunite pool, surrounded by a bluestone patio with multiple entertaining and lounging areas. A well-thought-out setting for summer gatherings or long days by the poolside. For the art enthusiast, a well-stocked library of art and design books can be found in the first-floor lounge. On the second floor, you will find four well-appointed bedrooms, including two that feature ensuite bathrooms, as well as an additional full bathroom. To enhance your stay, the dedicated laundry room features two washers and dryers for your convenience after days at the beach. Minutes from both Long Beach and Sag Harbor Village, you can also enjoy fresh, local produce from Serene Green Farm Stand, conveniently located at the end of Parkway Drive. [[Rental Registration # RP230356]] EH RR #: RP230356 Rental Terms: July: $60,000 August - Labor Day: $75,000 July - Labor Day: $135,000

SAG HARBOR VILLAGE WOW HOUSE! This lovely 1840's Village home was recently purchased and designed to create an open floor plan with high-end details. All brand new furnishings, fantastic art, beautiful light: it has a wonderful flow for easy living. There is an outdoor deck with a new grill and a dining table. The yard is serene with chairs around a fire pit. All new systems have been installed, including Central Air, an updated kitchen with glazed Moroccan white tiles, a Viking stove and hood, and 2-inch thick marble countertops. There are two new full baths, one upstairs with a tub and one downstairs with a shower. There are 3 bedrooms upstairs, with laundry. The spacious open living area flows into a dining area that's off the enclosed kitchen. There is a separate Den/TV room with a full bath on the main floor. A deck that overlooks a newly landscaped, hedged, and fenced-in lush garden with irrigation. Featuring a Barn/Storage. There is also a full lower level of clean space. New hedges have been installed at the front of the home for privacy with a new gated-entry portico. The rear yard is serene with plantings and is seemingly quiet. There is a two-car individual parking area to the side of the house, and the yard is gated and fenced with English-style gardens. This home is move-in ready and is surrounded by the choicest homes in the Village, while the designer's taste warrants savvy appreciation. This home is minutes to the village, dining, shopping, and transportation, with the Harbor Market just around the corner for morning coffee and croissants. Here you have a quiet residence in the heart of Sag Harbor Village, with quick access to Main Street, Shopping, Dining, and Beaches. Newly listed for the first time! [[Rental Registration # R-26-0002]] EH RR #: R-26-0002 Rental Terms: September: $31,500 August - Labor Day: $50,000 August: $25,000

New Kitchen Renovation!! Modern waterfront residence with expansive yard and private dock near Long Beach. Enjoy long summer days sailing, kayaking, swimming or swinging in the yard and followed by family bbqs. Great location with proximity to Sag Harbor village restaurants and shops and private outdoor oasis. Revel in spectacular sunset views from the wrap around deck with comfortable seating that is also perfect for outdoor dining and entertaining. Rental Reg. # RP201766 - Reg. Expires 6/07/2023 EH RR #: RP201766 Rental Terms: Other / Short Term - Year Round: $375,000

Step into the season with a top-to-bottom Spring refresh-brand new mattresses, crisp bedding and towels, a sparkling new kitchen stove, a sizzling barbecue, and a fresh coat of paint. Watch the sunsets dance across the water and feel the cool breezes that make every evening unforgettable. With a sandy entrance to Sag Harbor Cove for a refreshing dip and an outdoor shower to rinse off, it's the perfect blend of charm and modern comfort. This gem is priced right and ready for your best summer yet-just unpack and start making memories! [[Rental Registration # RA240090]] EH RR #: RA240090 Rental Terms: September: $10,000

Available for rent, this newly renovated Sag Harbor estate blends modern sophistication with laid-back coastal charm-perfect for a luxurious Hamptons escape. Fully gut-renovated and thoughtfully expanded, the 2,680 sq. ft. home features brand-new hardwood oak floors, Restoration Hardware finishes, a built-in sound system, and an abundance of natural light. The main living room boasts soaring ceilings, a custom bar, and seamless flow into the open-concept kitchen outfitted with top-of-the-line WOLF, Sub-Zero, and Miele appliances. With five bedrooms and four-and-a-half spa-like baths, the home comfortably accommodates guests, including two separate master suites with ensuite baths, soaking tubs, and walk-in showers. A flexible nursery space can serve as an office or dressing room, and a second private office at the entrance is ideal for remote work. Outside, enjoy a south-facing 0.58-acre property with a heated gunite pool, sun-drenched deck, lounge and dining areas, and lush landscaping. The home also includes solar panels, an electric car charger, a full laundry room, and deeded beach rights-perfect for launching kayaks or paddleboards. Just a mile from Long Beach and moments from Morton Wildlife Refuge and Noyac Golf Course, this rental offers the ultimate in Hamptons living. [[Rental Registration # RP251335]] EH RR #: RP251335 Rental Terms: July: $45,000 Other / Short Term - Dec: $15,000 October: $20,000 August - Labor Day: $60,000 August: $55,000 November: $15,000