luxury real estate for rent Shelter Island, United States

Enjoy a beautiful airy and bright mint condition Bay Front Orient Contemporary home, perfect for relaxing and entertaining. This 4-bedroom 4.5 bath home has gourmet kitchen, fireplace, open common space for easy entertaining. First floor has access to bay side screened porch from living room and den (or 4th bedroom with full bath). Second floor master bedroom and a guest bedroom open onto upper bay side deck, a third bedroom with full bath completes the layout. Private stairs to the beach and deeded beach rights to association Bay beach just a short walk from the house. Property is close to all village amenities: Country Store, Post Office, Marinas, Bay and Sound beaches. Available Apr $10,000; May $12,000; Sept $20,000; Oct $15,000; Nov $10,000; Dec $10,000. Permit# 1020.

Available Seasonally June 20K, August 16th-Labor Day15K, Available September 15K and October 15K TIMELESS TRANQUALITY ON GARDINERS BAY - An inviting seasonal beachfront retreat on Gardiners Bay, thoughtfully designed as a peaceful escape from the demands of everyday living. Begin your mornings with beautiful sunrises over the water and settle into the quiet rhythm of bayfront living throughout the day. The home offers an open airy layout with three full sized water-facing bedrooms, updated fully equipped kitchen and baths and comfortable modern amenities throughout. A generous enclosed porch provides a versatile space for dining, working remotely or simply slowing down. Outdoors, a charming portico invites alfresco meals with a gas grill while an outdoor shower completes the experience– an effortless calming setting for refined yet relaxed bayfront living. Fully furnished and equipped with necessary linens and towels. Close to fine dining, golf and a versatile selection of wineries for additional enjoyment and entertainment.

Impeccably restored 19th Century gem located in the heart of Orient Village with bay views. Close to bay and sound beaches, and a stroll to all village amenities. Featuring 2 parlors, 3 bedrooms, library, office, eat-in kitchen, updated baths, charming garden, out-door dining, and grill, out-door shower. Offered April $6,000; May $6,000; June $15,000; Sept $12,000. Permit #0483.

Authentic 1770 Cottage in the heart of Orient Village. Lovingly restored & maintained Village home on beautifully landscaped lot, offering private grounds & distant views of sunsets over the bay. Furnished in period antiques, screened-in porch off kitchen, first floor bedroom. Walk to amenities, bay beach, Yacht Club, marina, farm stand & Jitney. Offered Sept 3-Oct 3 for $8,000. Permit #0091.

Beautiful renovated 2-bedroom, 2 full bath home in Orient Village. Open concept – living/dining/gourmet kitchen. Lower level with screening room, office, full bath. Walk from Jitney. Enjoy all village amenities, bay & sound beaches. Close to Orient Beach State Park & Cross Sound Ferry. Available April $5,000; May $5,000; June $7,000; July $15,000; Aug $15,000; Sept $8,000. Permit# 1364.

Offered July $35,000; Aug $35,000; Sept $25,000; Oct $20,000. Elegantly renovated and exceptionally spacious, this contemporary retreat is nestled within a parklike setting of sweeping lawns, lush gardens, and mature landscaping that affords remarkable privacy. Refined outdoor amenities include a heated gunite pool, outdoor shower, firepit, and walking path to abutting Island’s End Golf & Country Club. The main house and annex are filled with natural light, featuring soaring ceilings, oversized windows, and glass doors that open seamlessly to two expansive decks for effortless indoor-outdoor living. A generous poolside patio offers additional space for lounging and entertaining, while the decks provide inviting areas for alfresco dining, grilling, and relaxation. Bedrooms are thoughtfully positioned to ensure comfort and privacy for guests. Peaceful and secluded, yet just moments from Greenport Village, Seps Farm Stand, and sound and bay beaches, this home is impeccably suited for gracious North Fork entertaining.

2026 Rates: April $7,500; May $12K; June $15K; July $25K; A1-LD $27,500; Sept $12,500; October $10K: This beautifully curated home away from home, blends modern design with warmth and style. Experience elegant comfort in your private retreat with natural light, modern decor and thoughtful touches throughout. Nestled on a quiet, tree lined street, this special haven features a front porch, fully equipped open kitchen, and spacious backyard with a pool and fire pit. Enjoy all season living in this home away from home just a 10 minute walk to The LIRR station, Hampton Jitney, and The North Ferry.

Offered Sept $8,000. Enjoy the ease of summer on the North Fork in this classic 1910 hilltop home overlooking Orient Bay and Long Island Sound. A three-sided wraparound porch extends the main living spaces outdoors through multiple glass doors, creating a seamless indoor-outdoor flow filled with light and salt breezes. Inside, the home offers inviting spaces for gathering, including a spacious living room with a wood-burning fireplace, a formal dining room, and a generous eat-in kitchen with a butler’s pantry. A TV room/bedroom and full bath complete the ground floor. Upstairs are five bedrooms, including a primary bedroom with a private balcony and half bath, along with a full bath for the four additional bedrooms. The private grounds include an in-ground pool. Latham’s Farm Stand and Orient Village are just a short walk away. September is an ideal time to enjoy this peaceful, timeless retreat.

Not available for year round rent at this time. Newly renovated three bedroom, two bath bungalow just outside of popular Greenport Village. This house provides a sense of privacy and relaxation close to the beach. Located less than one mile away, the captivating Rocky Point Beach is a picturesque retreat for everyone to enjoy. Additionally, there is the exquisite Truman's Beach nearby, which provides a stunning view of Connecticut. Lavender Bay and Sep's Farm are conveniently located only 0.4 miles away. The exterior of the property is designed for entertainment, featuring a spacious patio, barbecue area, fire pit, and even an outdoor shower to refresh after a dip in the nearby beaches. Seasonal Rates: June $6,000 , July $8,000 , Aug-LD $10,000

Stunning waterfront shingle style home overlooking Long Island Sound with private beach access. Waterview, heated pool. Wrap-around porch. Original beach stone fireplace, vintage beadboard walls, large, updated gourmet kitchen, open common area, 5 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, large master ensuite with private screen water view balcony. Beautiful interior furnishings, with teak rocking chairs, chaise lounges and picnic table on porch and pool area for entertaining. Close to Orient Village amenities, marinas, Country store, Yacht Club, and bay beaches. Offered June 3-27 $28,000; Sept 2-16 $14,000. Permit# 1108.

2026 Rates: June $8,500/week; July and August $10,000/week (Two Week Minimum For All Rentals). Spend your summer in style at this exquisite brand-new modern farmhouse, offering the perfect blend of luxury, comfort, and North Fork charm. Located just minutes from Greenport Village, local farmstands, renowned wineries, and pristine beaches, this home is the ideal summer retreat. Set on a full 1-acre lot, this spacious and sun-filled residence features an open-concept layout with elegant hardwood floors throughout. The heart of the home is a high-end chef’s kitchen, fully equipped for entertaining and flowing seamlessly into a stylish living area complete with a gas fireplace—perfect for unwinding after a day on the Sound. The first-floor primary ensuite bedroom offers a serene private escape, while the second floor includes a junior ensuite and two additional guest bedrooms with a shared full bath—providing ample space and comfort for family and friends. Step outside to your own private oasis featuring a 20x40 heated in-ground pool, surrounded by lush landscaping and plenty of space for outdoor dining and lounging. Whether you’re sipping wine under the stars, enjoying a day at the beach, or exploring nearby Greenport’s vibrant shops and restaurants, this stunning farmhouse offers the ultimate summer experience.

This Sag Harbor home offers a unique opportunity to be able to vacation in a beautifully renovated and tastefully decorated home in the middle of all the action - boating, dining, theater, shopping, swimming. This three-level home takes full advantage of the water views with a living area and wet bar on the third floor. The chef's kitchen flows seamlessly into both indoor & outdoor dining options - great for entertaining. All of the bedrooms have access to a private bathroom - two bedrooms are en-suite. The fourth bedroom is being used as a third-floor lounge area and has a pull out couch for guests. The lower level is fully finished and offers a cozy space for rainy days and functions well as a home office with natural light and walk-out access to the backyard garden. There is a full bathroom and laundry on the lower level as well. Rental Terms: August - Labor Day: $55,000 September: $40,000

Spend the summer in Sag Harbor-arguably the Hamptons' most vibrant and sought-after destination. Set on half an acre just moments from the village, this five-bedroom home is being offered as a rental for the first time, presenting a rare opportunity to experience Sag Harbor living at its best. With effortless access to the village's renowned restaurants, shops, and marinas, the home offers the ideal balance of privacy and convenience, complemented by stunning views over the bay. Designed for summer living, the open-concept main level flows seamlessly from kitchen to dining to outdoor entertaining, with multiple sets of glass doors opening to the grounds. A separate living room with fireplace provides a quiet counterpoint to the home's airy, social spaces. Upstairs, the primary suite offers a private retreat with its own deck overlooking the property and capturing beautiful water views, while additional bedrooms are thoughtfully arranged across two wings for comfort and flexibility. Outside, a heated gunite pool anchors the grounds-perfect for long afternoons, casual gatherings, and easy evenings under the stars. Ideally positioned for both relaxation and access, this is a turnkey Sag Harbor rental designed to capture the very best of the Hamptons summer. Rental Terms: Other / Short Term - 5/28/2027 - 6/30/2027: $50,000 June: $45,000

Bright and spacious Contemporary summer rental on the North Fork. Featuring floor to ceiling windows, great room, 6 bedrooms, 3.5 bathrooms, eat-in kitchen, recreation room. Private back yard with 40x20 salt water heated pool. Offered June $25,000; July 1-23 $27,000 (RENTED); Aug 1-15 $20,000; Sept 9-30 $18,000. Permit #1230.

Welcome to 54 Bay View Drive East, Sag Harbor, where modern luxury meets waterfront living. This stunning, award-winning modern estate is a boater's paradise, boasting a deep water dock and breathtaking sunset views over Sag Harbor Cove. With 4 bedrooms, 4.5 modern baths, and 3100 square feet of sleek living space, this home offers the epitome of waterfront elegance. A primary suite on the first floor and an additional secondary primary bedroom suite on the second floor with endless water views complement this unique offering. Enjoy the convenience of a water view Chef's kitchen, multi-level decks, and a heated Gunite infinity pool. The property features geothermal heating and cooling, ensuring comfort with minimal environmental impact. Custom fixtures from Italy and an outdoor wood-burning pizza oven add distinctive charm. Located near Sag Harbor's amenities, a 10 min walk to Long Beach, and the Shelter Island Ferry, this home offers a unique summer retreat. Don't miss the opportunity to experience waterfront luxury at its finest. [[Rental Registration # 251021]] EH RR #: 251021 Rental Terms: August: $185,000 August - Labor Day: $225,000

Also Available May 24 - Jul 31 $235K, Sep 4 - Nov 30 $160K Historic Sag Harbor, brilliantly renovated, offers sophisticated, relaxed stylish living. The 1750 Main house offers delightful, light, entertaining public spaces, luxurious en-suite bedrooms and staff quarters. The Carriage house offers added entertaining space with rare architectural features. This rare, near acre, village compound includes an oversized gunite pool, stone terracing, gracious garden dining and entertaining surrounded by a classic garden featuring historic box hedges, cherry trees and wonderful privacy. Rental Terms: Memorial Day - Labor Day: $425,000 July - Labor Day: $335,000 July: $140,000 August - Labor Day: $195,000 Other / Short Term - May 24 - Jun 30: $95,000

2026 Rates: May $26,000; June $29,000; July $36,000; September $27,000; October $24,000. Experience North Fork summer living in this newly constructed gem! Nestled in the sought-after Stirling Eastern Shores community, this impeccably designed modern farmhouse offers exclusive access to a private Long Island Sound beach, just a five minute walk from the property. Step inside to discover a light-filled and meticulously styled interior adorned with contemporary finishes and furnishings. The heart of the home is the chef's kitchen seamlessly integrated into the Great Room and anchored by a cozy gas fireplace. On the first floor, you'll find a convenient half bath, a junior en-suite bedroom, a spacious mudroom, and a sizeable 2-car garage. Ascend to the second level to encounter two additional guest bedrooms sharing a full bathroom, along with a stunning primary en-suite bedroom. The primary bath boasts a luxurious double vanity, a walk-in shower, a soaking tub, and an expansive walk-in closet for added convenience and indulgence. Outside, the property showcases a captivating landscape featuring a sprawling stone patio enveloping a 20x40 heated salt-water pool, complemented by an outdoor shower - an ideal setting for hosting gatherings and enjoying the summer sun.

SAG HARBOR VILLAGE WOW HOUSE! This lovely 1840's Village home was recently purchased and designed to create an open floor plan with high-end details. All brand new furnishings, fantastic art, beautiful light: it has a wonderful flow for easy living. There is an outdoor deck with a new grill and a dining table. The yard is serene with chairs around a fire pit. All new systems have been installed, including Central Air, an updated kitchen with glazed Moroccan white tiles, a Viking stove and hood, and 2-inch thick marble countertops. There are two new full baths, one upstairs with a tub and one downstairs with a shower. There are 3 bedrooms upstairs, with laundry. The spacious open living area flows into a dining area that's off the enclosed kitchen. There is a separate Den/TV room with a full bath on the main floor. A deck that overlooks a newly landscaped, hedged, and fenced-in lush garden with irrigation. Featuring a Barn/Storage. There is also a full lower level of clean space. New hedges have been installed at the front of the home for privacy with a new gated-entry portico. The rear yard is serene with plantings and is seemingly quiet. There is a two-car individual parking area to the side of the house, and the yard is gated and fenced with English-style gardens. This home is move-in ready and is surrounded by the choicest homes in the Village, while the designer's taste warrants savvy appreciation. This home is minutes to the village, dining, shopping, and transportation, with the Harbor Market just around the corner for morning coffee and croissants. Here you have a quiet residence in the heart of Sag Harbor Village, with quick access to Main Street, Shopping, Dining, and Beaches. Newly listed for the first time! [[Rental Registration # R-26-0002]] EH RR #: R-26-0002 Rental Terms: September: $31,500 August - Labor Day: $50,000 August: $25,000

Experience breathtaking views of Long Island Sound and Orient Point County Park from this spacious open-concept home. Beautifully updated 4-bed, 4-bath home offers private 20x40 heated saltwater pool and serene backyard. Host memorable gatherings in the spacious kitchen, perfect for indoor & outdoor dining. The expansive master suite boasts breathtaking views, king-size bed, office nook, dressing area, full bath, and private balcony. The lower level features a cozy sitting and entertainment room, an exercise room, a full bathroom, laundry facilities, a 2-car garage, and direct access to the pool and backyard. Enjoy easy access to the pristine sound beach, hiking trails, Orient State Park, and Duryeas restaurant. Located at the tip of Long Island, this exceptional home is perfect for anyone seeking coastal living with ample entertainment and relaxation space. Offered Apr $11,000; May $20,000; June $25,000; July $35,000 (RENTED); July 31-Aug14 $20,000; Aug15-Sept 8 (RENTED); Sept 10-30 $20,000; Oct $20,000; Nov $15,000. Permit# 0234.

2026 Rates: August 1-15 $20,000, September $25,000, October $20,000: Escape to this exceptional seasonal rental, perfectly situated on the shores of the Long Island Sound. This beautifully appointed waterfront home offers the ultimate coastal living experience, featuring private stairs leading directly to the beach, an in-ground heated gunite pool, and panoramic water views from nearly every room. With 4 spacious bedrooms—including a luxurious primary en-suite—and 3 full bathrooms, there’s plenty of room for family and guests to unwind in comfort. The heart of the home is a dramatic post and beam Great Room, designed for both relaxing and entertaining, with soaring ceilings and expansive windows that flood the space with natural light. Step out onto the large balcony to take in sweeping views of the Sound, enjoy morning coffee as the sun rises over the water, or end the day with a spectacular sunset. Additional amenities include a 1-car garage, central air, and thoughtfully landscaped grounds that ensure privacy and tranquility. Whether you’re lounging poolside, walking along the shoreline, or enjoying evening breezes from the balcony, this home offers an unforgettable seasonal escape.

Beautiful Bucolic Waterfront -- Best Sunsets in the Hamptons. Overlooking Noyak Bay, this newly constructed, triple-mint, modern manor boasts breathtaking water views and stunning sunsets. The soaring floor to ceiling windows, expansive decking, heated gunite waterside pool, plush outdoor furniture, cozy fire pit, outdoor shower and Lynx professional grill, adorn the water side veranda, creating a grand and sumptuous Hamptons experience. So, too, this property has a rare and coveted private deep water dock for backyard paddle boarding, kayaking or...bring your own boat. Ideal for entertaining, this home is appointed with an Il Forno pizza oven, sous vide technology, an outdoor herb garden and an enviable array of Japanese chef's knives, surely to fascinate the boldest of home chef's. With rich oak, warm walnut and modern steel finishes this property exudes serenity and grace and is sure to impress. Impeccably decorated and beautifully appointed, this modern retreat is mired among majestic marine sea grasses which, like a metronome, sway in time to the warm coastal breezes. Conveniently located in the up and coming beach community of Pine Neck. Minutes from ocean beaches, a stone's throw from historic downtown Sag Harbor and a short drive from Bridgehampton, this 5200 square foot, 5 bed room, 6 bath jewel is not to be missed. [[Rental Registration # RP220659]] EH RR #: RP220659 Rental Terms: Two Weeks: $140,000 August: $250,000 August - Labor Day: $275,000 Other / Short Term - Weekly: $70,000 Memorial Day - Labor Day: $550,000 July: $250,000

This beautiful and very spacious 4,400 +/- square foot home nestled on two acres in the woods has so much to offer. Amenities include two living areas, a formal dining room, large kitchen and eight bedrooms including a generous primary suite and two junior suites. Its convenient location offers easy access to coveted summer locales including Southampton, Sag Harbor, Bridgehampton and Water Mill. The large covered back deck overlooks a very private pool and gazebo and is wonderful for outdoor entertaining, rain or shine. With a gated property entrance, this is an ideal summer getaway that is primed for family and friends. [[Rental Registration # RP180238]] EH RR #: RP260110 Rental Terms: Other / Short Term - Year Round: $120,000 July - Labor Day: $100,000 August - Labor Day: $35,000 Memorial Day - Labor Day: $125,000