luxury houses for sale North Eleuthera, Bahamas

Gently elevated in a quiet enclave of Gregory Town, the Artist’s Colony presides over the shimmering waters of Pitman’s Cove. This historic estate unfolds within a walled compound of lush, mature gardens, where palms, flowering fauna, and fruit-bearing trees create an atmosphere of serene seclusion and natural beauty. Signature Features • Elevated waterfront estate overlooking Pitman’s Cove • Four-bedroom main residence, each with ensuite, sitting area, and private patio • Extensive renovations including metal alloy roof and restored wood floors • Newly built chef’s kitchen with premium appliances and dual decks • Separate Great Cottage Room, ideal as an artist atelier or studio • Distinctive star-shaped living pavilion with terrace and sea views • Private access to the cove via terraced staircase • Designed by renowned architect Ray Nathaniels, student of Frank Lloyd Wright • Lush walled gardens with mature palms and fruit trees • Rich cultural legacy with notable past guests Main Residence The principal home offers four generously proportioned bedrooms, each thoughtfully appointed with its own ensuite bathroom, closet, sitting area, and private patio that captures sweeping views of the sea. The interiors have been meticulously restored, featuring elegant wood flooring, storm windows, and refined finishes complemented by high-end furnishings. Recent upgrades include a durable metal alloy roof, ensuring both longevity and peace of mind, while maintaining the home’s timeless architectural integrity. Kitchen At the heart of the home, the newly constructed chef’s kitchen is both functional and inviting. Anchored by a central island and outfitted with premium appliances, it seamlessly connects to dual wooden decks on either side. Sliding doors and storm windows frame tranquil garden and ocean vistas, allowing natural light and coastal breezes to enhance the culinary experience. Great Cottage Room A network of garden pathways leads to the Great Cottage Room, the original artist’s workspace. This distinctive pentagonal structure, complete with an ensuite bathroom, remains unrenovated, offering a rare opportunity to restore or reimagine the space. True to the estate’s creative heritage, it is ideally suited as an artist’s atelier, music studio, or private retreat. Living Pavilion & Outdoor Experience Closer to the water’s edge, a striking star-shaped structure serves as the estate’s living room. With its expansive terrace and uninterrupted sea views, it is a captivating setting for relaxation or entertaining. A nearby banyan tree provides natural shade, enhancing the tranquil ambiance. From here, a terraced staircase descends gracefully to the cove, inviting moments of sun-soaked leisure and refreshing swims in the crystalline waters. Grounds & Gardens Encircling the estate, the lush gardens are a defining feature, offering both beauty and privacy. Mature palms sway gently above flowering plants and fruit trees, creating a verdant sanctuary within the walled compound. Every pathway reveals a new perspective, blending cultivated elegance with the natural charm of the island landscape. Heritage & Provenance Originally conceived in the 1960s, the Artist’s Colony was designed by esteemed Bahamas-based architect Ray Nathaniels, a protégé of Frank Lloyd Wright. Over the decades, it has welcomed an array of distinguished guests, including Burt Lancaster, Richard Widmark, President Jimmy Carter, and Denzel Washington. Lovingly and thoughtfully restored, the estate honors its architectural pedigree while embracing modern comforts. This exceptional property presents a rare convergence of history, artistry, and coastal living. Whether envisioned as a private sanctuary or a uniquely positioned opportunity for boutique commercial development, the Artist’s Colony offers an extraordinary canvas upon which to create a legacy in one of Eleuthera’s most enchanting settings.

Perched along the leeward ridge of Eleuthera Island Shores, Surfer’s Cottage is a quintessential Bahamian retreat capturing sweeping Atlantic vistas, cooling breezes, and radiant sunsets. Just minutes from the world famous Surfer’s Beach, this charming island hideaway blends relaxed comfort with an enviable location at the heart of Eleuthera’s natural beauty. Signature Features • Three bedroom, one bathroom island cottage • Elevated setting with spectacular Atlantic views • Exceptional sunsets and steady leeward breezes • Moments to Surfer’s Beach, one of Eleuthera’s top surf breaks • Vaulted ceilings and bright, airy interiors • Expansive ocean view verandah for relaxing and entertaining • Seamless indoor to outdoor flow • Close to Gregory Town dining, shops, beaches, and attractions • Ideal as a vacation home, rental property, or full time residence Main Living Spaces The cottage’s open concept living and dining area forms the heart of the home, enhanced by island style vaulted ceilings and exposed beams that create an atmosphere of relaxed authenticity. Large windows draw in natural light and frame lush tropical landscape along with sweeping Atlantic views, allowing the interiors to feel connected to the surrounding natural environment. A playful, colourful kitchen adds character and warmth, thoughtfully positioned to support easy movement between indoor gathering areas and the expansive verandah beyond. Bedrooms and Bath Three inviting bedrooms offer comfortable accommodations for family and guests. Each room benefits from the home’s gentle cross breezes and elevated position, fostering a peaceful ambience throughout. A well maintained bathroom serves the residence, complementing the cottage’s bright, breezy layout. Outdoor Living The expansive verandah is the home’s defining feature, wrapped in turquoise accents and flowing white curtains that shift gently with the breeze. This elevated perch invites quiet mornings overlooking the ocean, leisurely afternoons in the shade, and evenings illuminated by vivid Eleuthera sunsets. It is an effortlessly enchanting space for dining, lounging, or admiring the surrounding beauty. Location and Lifestyle Situated a short drive from Gregory Town, the cottage provides convenient access to beloved restaurants, local shops, pineapple fields, and many of Eleuthera’s most celebrated beaches. Moments away, iconic Surfer’s Beach offers pristine waters and consistent waves, drawing surfers and beach lovers year round. This prime location allows residents to enjoy both the island’s relaxed rhythm and its abundant natural attractions. Whether envisioned as a private island escape, an income producing rental, or a comfortable full time residence, Surfer’s Cottage captures the essence of Eleuthera living with postcard views, uplifting breezes, and a setting that embodies the island’s timeless appeal.

Perched high above the dramatic Atlantic cliffs of North Eleuthera, Seaspray Estate is a rare 1.65-acre double-lot sanctuary offering an impressive 245 feet of pristine ocean frontage and sweeping panoramic views. From its elevated vantage point, the estate captures breathtaking sunrises, refreshing ocean breezes, and the untouched natural beauty that defines this spectacular coastline. The home underwent a full renovation in 2024, blending modern comfort with timeless island elegance. Spacious & Refined Interiors Designed for relaxed yet refined island living, the main residence features four spacious bedrooms and three bathrooms, complemented by a versatile bonus room ready to accommodate a new owner’s vision — whether as a private office, fitness studio, or additional guest bedroom. Expansive balconies and stunning terraces create seamless indoor-outdoor living, providing exceptional spaces for entertaining or simply taking in the endless Atlantic horizon. Versatile Guest Cottage An attached efficiency cottage enhances the property’s versatility, complete with a full kitchen, bedroom, and bathroom — ideal for guests, extended family, or private staff accommodations. Steps From Iconic Shores Seaspray Estate also enjoys close proximity to Bottom Harbour, renowned for its world-class snorkeling, diving, and frequent turtle sightings, as well as the public park at Harbour Beach — an expansive stretch of approximately 1,000 feet of beautiful shoreline. Offering elevated oceanfront living, modern updates, and remarkable natural surroundings, Seaspray Estate presents an extraordinary opportunity to own a private retreat in one of North Eleuthera’s most captivating coastal settings.

Just moments from Eleuthera’s legendary Surfer’s Beach and the charming village of Gregory Town, Tattoo’s Garden Casita is a newly remodeled two-bedroom residence that captures the essence of relaxed island living. Set within lush tropical gardens, this thoughtfully redesigned home offers privacy, style, and effortless access to one of the island’s most celebrated coastal settings. Signature Features • Newly remodeled two-bedroom island residence near Surfer’s Beach • Located minutes from Gregory Town in a sought-after Eleuthera setting • Reversed floor plan designed for privacy and elevated living spaces • Lush tropical gardens creating a secluded, sanctuary-like atmosphere • Vaulted great room with exposed beams and tongue-and-groove ceilings • Chef’s kitchen with concrete countertops, island seating, and modern appliances • Private balcony with hammock swings and garden views • Wrap-around patio with shaded dining, BBQ, and enclosed outdoor shower • Ideal as a private retreat or high-performing vacation rental Design & Layout A winding stone pathway leads through mature palms and native foliage to a welcoming entry, setting the tone for the tranquil experience within. The home’s reversed floor plan places two private bedrooms on the ground level, each opening directly to the wrap-around patio and garden, allowing for seamless indoor-outdoor living. Upper-Level Living Areas The second level unfolds into a dramatic vaulted great room filled with natural light and cooling breezes. Exposed beams and black-stained tongue-and-groove ceilings add warmth and character, while the open layout connects the kitchen, dining area, and lounge. A private balcony with hammock swings provides a peaceful perch for sunset cocktails and quiet moments overlooking the gardens, with distant ocean glimpses beyond. Kitchen & Entertaining The chef’s kitchen is both stylish and functional, featuring concrete countertops, a central island with bar seating, a built-in convection cooktop, dishwasher, and modern appliances. Adjacent dining and lounge areas create an inviting setting for entertaining or relaxed evenings at home. Outdoor Living Designed for both gathering and reflection, the patio offers shaded dining, a BBQ area, and a spacious enclosed outdoor shower, ideal for rinsing off after a day at the beach or enjoying a starlit shower surrounded by nature. The lush gardens enhance privacy and reinforce the home’s serene island atmosphere. Tattoo’s Garden Casita blends timeless Bahamian charm with contemporary comfort in one of Eleuthera’s most desirable locations. Whether enjoyed as a peaceful island escape or positioned as a compelling vacation rental, this residence offers an inviting lifestyle defined by natural beauty, thoughtful design, and proximity to world-class surf and beaches.

This oceanfront property on the southern border of Gregory Town Eleuthera is a unique gem with numerous options. The house, spanning 2,800 sq. ft., is situated on the northwest corner of the property, offering stunning ocean views from both floors. Thanks to the recent solar system upgrades and cement-filled block walls, it boasts excellent energy efficiency and economical power usage. The property features a separate garage and multiple natural paths that traverse the land. These paths lead to a custom observation deck perched on the cliff's edge, providing breathtaking views of the Caribbean side of Eleuthera. Additionally, the paths wind through the natural landscape, showcasing various local fruit trees and plants at different elevations. This property offers flexibility for subdivision, either at the time of purchase or later, with all potential lots having direct access to the main road as per existing plans. The interior of the house features 2 bedrooms and 2.5 bathrooms, with the second floor having the ability to be utilized as a third bedroom with the addition of a fold-out sofa bed. Both levels have patios to enjoy the scenic views. The open floor plan allows for cool ocean breezes and views from the living, dining, and kitchen areas. The separate garage provides ample space for two vehicles, with additional room for a workspace. Thanks to its solid construction, including filled cement block walls, storm windows, and circular shape, along with its elevated position from the ocean, the house is well-protected from hurricane damage. The property offers a good buffer between neighbors and plenty of land for expansion, additional structures, or subdivision.

Baycienda sits across from the Atlantic Ocean, making it possible to wake up to the sound of rolling waves each and every day. Situated a mere one mile south of Harbour Island and Historic Dunmore Town, is a perfect proximity to what is known as the first settlement and capital of the Bahamas. This sprawling and captivating villa includes a floor plan designed with 4 bedrooms and 3 baths. An open concept floor plan makes it easy to travel between living, dining and sleeping spaces throughout the day and night. The fully equipped kitchen is ideal to serve up something savory. The living room hosts tasteful and island-inspired furnishings while the dining space includes two tables with the capacity to seat up persons at a time. The combination of tiled flooring and decorative stone accents throughout the villa brings the look together and balances out modern conveniences with rustic charm as well.Baycienda includes access to a private dock and 17-foot center console boat as well.

Sea and sky take center stage at this newly constructed oceanfront residence, a contemporary 2-bedroom, 2-bathroom home completed in 2025 and set on over an acre of pristine coastline in Whale Point, Eleuthera. Designed to capture the beauty of its natural surroundings, this modern retreat offers 2,650 square feet of open concept living with seamless indoor and outdoor flow and 150 feet of breathtaking Atlantic frontage, creating an effortless canvas for relaxed, elegant island living. Signature Features: •Newly constructed oceanfront home completed in 2025 •Over 1-acre of pristine coastal land in Whale Point, Eleuthera •Approximately 2,650 square feet of interior living space •150-feet of spectacular Atlantic Ocean frontage •Both bedrooms are ocean facing with sweeping sea views •Expansive 800 square foot deck extending from the main living area •Turn-key residence with brand new appliances and furnishings •Automatic generator for comfort, reliability, and peace of mind •Foundation already poured for a future guest cottage, offering expansion potential •Moments from Whale Point Beach and Bottom Harbour, renowned for exceptional snorkeling Oceanfront Living & Layout At the heart of the residence is a generous open concept living space that flows effortlessly toward the ocean. Large openings frame uninterrupted water views and invite soft sea breezes throughout the day, creating a bright and airy atmosphere that feels connected to the surrounding landscape. The thoughtful layout emphasizes ease, comfort, and an intuitive connection between the interior and the expansive outdoor living areas. Bedrooms & Interior Comfort Both bedrooms are purposefully positioned along the ocean side of the home, allowing you to wake each morning to the sound of waves and a panorama of sea and sky. Each bedroom captures wide views of the Atlantic, reinforcing the sense of retreat and calm that defines the property. Brand new appliances and furnishings throughout the home ensure a fully turn key experience, allowing you to step directly into a refined, modern island lifestyle. Outdoor Living & Expansion Potential A spacious 800 square foot deck extends seamlessly from the main living area, providing an ideal setting for entertaining, relaxing, or watching spectacular sunrises over the Atlantic. This elevated outdoor space offers ample room for dining, lounging, and quiet contemplation, all against the backdrop of endless ocean views. The property also includes a foundation already poured for a future guest cottage, offering a rare opportunity to expand the estate with additional accommodations tailored to your needs. Whale Point Beach & Natural Surroundings Just moments from the residence lies the phenomenal Whale Point Beach, your gateway to Bottom Harbour, a protected, crystalline haven celebrated for its vibrant marine life. Here, sea turtles, eagle rays, and schools of tropical fish animate the clear waters, offering some of the finest snorkeling and ocean exploration in North Eleuthera. The setting combines peace and privacy with extraordinary natural beauty, enhancing both lifestyle appeal and long-term desirability. This exceptional oceanfront property embodies modern Bahamian elegance and effortless coastal luxury. With new construction, generous acreage, dramatic Atlantic frontage, and immediate access to one of Eleuthera’s most captivating marine environments, it presents a rare opportunity to own a contemporary, turn-key oceanfront home in one of the island’s most sought-after enclaves.

Embraced by the turquoise hues of the ocean from its exclusive and private setting, Middle Cay, a private island in Eleuthera, offers a lifestyle that many can only dream of. This two-acre island is highly accessible with the North Eleuthera airport being close by and Harbour Island---s many restaurants and shops are only minutes away by boat. Middle Cay offers two residences, a 4-bedroom main home and a 3-bedroom guest cottage.The Main home has an open kitchen and dining space with stainless steel appliances, granite countertops, and a dining table that seats 8. The living room opens to a private patio where you can enjoy a heated pool and an outdoor shower. The Main home---s spacious master suite offers a king bed and three walls of panoramic ocean views, a private patio, a lounge area and an en-suite bathroom. The second suite has two double beds, a picturesque window seat and an en-suite bathroom. The third suite has two twin beds, ocean views, and a hall bathroom and the fourth suite has a king bed and en-suite bathroom. The cottage features a spacious living area with beautiful, exposed wooden beams and tile floors. There---s room for dining at the bar and main table and the living area opens to patio and offers three walls of windows for incredible ocean views. The cottage offers three bedrooms including a king suite with exterior access, ocean views, and an ensuite bathroom. The second suite has two double beds, exterior access, and an ensuite bathroom. The third suite is ideal for children, with a twin bunk, trundle bed, and access to a half bathroom Additional highlights of this property include a working lighthouse, two docks, a boat lift, a fire pit and the property is being sold fully equipped including fishing gear, kayaks and paddle boards. The island---s location is unsurpassed as the area is well known for its pink sand beaches, prime snorkeling among shipwrecks and vibrant reefs and mainland Eleuthera, Spanish Wells and Harbour Island are easily accessible for those wishing to island hop. Middle Cay provides the ultimate privacy with access to so many amenities and nearby activities. The sense of peace and relaxation you experience while being on Middle Cay is simply hard to describe.

Nestled on over an acre in the peaceful community of Whale Point, Eleuthera, Unwind and Chillax offer a rare chance to own a beautifully designed dual-residence retreat that captures the relaxed sophistication of island living. With 150 feet of ocean frontage and deep, spacious grounds, the property provides exceptional privacy and sweeping natural beauty. Just moments away is the stunning Whale Point Beach , your pathway to Bottom Harbour, a protected, crystal-clear oasis teeming with vibrant marine life. Sea turtles, eagle rays, and colorful fish make this one of the most enchanting snorkeling spots in North Eleuthera. The main home, Unwind , features 2 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms across a bright and breezy layout of 1,200 sqft., complemented by a generous covered porch space of 900 sqft. that is perfect for outdoor dining, lounging, and taking in the ocean views. The home is outfitted with practical modern comforts including an automatic generator, instant hot water, and Starlink internet, ensuring effortless living whether you're here seasonally or year-round. Completed in 2025, the guest cottage Chillax offers the same welcoming charm with 625 sqft. of living space and 575 sqft. of decking. With 1 bedroom, 1 bathroom, and inviting indoor-outdoor living areas, it serves as a private sanctuary for visiting friends and family or a peaceful secondary residence. It also includes instant hot water and Starlink connectivity for added convenience. Property Highlights: • Over 1 acre in the peaceful Whale Point community • 150 feet of ocean frontage with exceptional privacy • Dual-residence layout: Unwind (main home) + Chillax (guest cottage) • Steps from Whale Point Beach and Bottom Harbour • Modern comforts: automatic generator, instant hot water, Starlink internet • Guest cottage also includes instant hot water and Starlink convenience • Close to beaches, coves, cultural attractions & boating/snorkeling hotspots • A harmonious blend of modern comfort and timeless Bahamian charm Whale Point’s location is both scenic and convenient, offering easy access to Harbour Island, North Eleuthera International Airport, Spanish Wells, and the many beaches, coves, and cultural gems of Central Eleuthera. Whether you love boating, snorkeling, beachcombing, or simply taking in the shoreline, this area has something for everyone. Together, Unwind and Chillax create a distinctive island compound where modern comfort meets timeless Bahamian charm—an elegant, serene retreat in one of Eleuthera’s most captivating settings.

Timeless Stone Cottage on 1+ Acre with 207 ft. Waterfront and a Private Cove Discover one of the most enduring and resilient homes in Current—a beautifully crafted stone cottage that has gracefully withstood the test of time. Set on just over an acre with an impressive 207 feet of waterfront, this property includes its own private beach cove, offering unmatched privacy, serenity, and a truly authentic island living experience. Perched on an elevated ridge, the cottage captures breathtaking views of crystal-clear turquoise waters from sunrise to sunset. Built from stone and concrete, the home is as charming as it is sturdy—a rare blend of old-world craftsmanship and Bahamian character. Recent upgrades include new windows and doors, enhancing both comfort and efficiency while preserving the cottage’s timeless feel. Outdoor living is a highlight, with three separate courtyard spaces perfect for lounging, dining, or simply enjoying the gentle ocean breezes. A substantial stone-and-concrete garage sits nearby and presents an immediate opportunity—whether envisioned as a future guest cottage, artist studio, or additional living space. With over an acre of waterfront land, the possibilities for expansion or redevelopment are truly limitless. Current itself is experiencing thoughtful growth, with new development on the horizon, making this a strategic and exciting place to invest. Perfectly positioned for convenience, the property is just 8 minutes from North Eleuthera International Airport, approximately 20 minutes door-to-dock to Harbour Island, and about 35 minutes total to Spanish Wells. Offering privacy, strength, charm, and future potential, this is one of Current’s most compelling and enduring waterfront opportunities. For more information or to schedule a showing, contact Colleen Carey at 1.242.818.6038 or [email protected]