luxury listed houses for sale Amagansett, United States

Introducing 434 on Main, a distinctive hospitality and investment opportunity in the heart of Amagansett. Set on .66 acre along coveted Main Street and just 0.36 miles from the ocean, this historic 1905 property is currently zoned and operated as an inn, offering an exceptional opportunity to establish or continue a boutique hospitality concept in one of the Hamptons' most sought-after destinations. Originally known as Sunset View Lodge, the property was meticulously restored in 2013-2014, undergoing extensive structural and mechanical improvements that reinforced its exceptional bones while preserving the character and craftsmanship of its turn-of-the-century origins. The main building features four beautifully appointed guest rooms, each with its own private ensuite bath, complemented by gracious common areas including formal living and dining rooms, a chef's kitchen, and a first-floor powder room. Front and rear staircases provide excellent circulation and separation between spaces-particularly well suited to an inn or bed-and-breakfast operation. A welcoming wraparound porch creates an immediate sense of arrival and offers an inviting setting for guests to enjoy the atmosphere of Amagansett. A newly finished lower level with approximately 9-foot ceilings provides substantial additional space and flexibility for storage, operations, amenities, or other permitted uses. The property's expansive grounds further distinguish the offering. Mature landscaping, sun-filled gardens, and intimate outdoor seating areas create the type of private, experiential setting increasingly sought after in boutique hospitality. An early barn structure, currently utilized as a studio and garage, adds another compelling dimension to the property and speaks to its deep connection to Amagansett's history. The barn also carries its own cultural provenance, having once served as the studio of acclaimed artist Bill Durham, a 1998 Pollock-Krasner grant recipient whose work is represented in collections including Guild Hall. With prominent Main Street presence, four ensuite accommodations, generous grounds, historic character, and exceptional proximity to Amagansett's shops, restaurants, transportation, and ocean beaches, 434 on Main presents a compelling opportunity for an owner-operator, hospitality entrepreneur, or investor seeking a distinctive presence in the Hamptons. Minutes from Amagansett Village, moments from the LIRR and Hampton Jitney, and less than a half mile from the ocean, 434 on Main offers the setting, history, and infrastructure for a truly special East End hospitality experience.