luxury real estate for sale Shelter Island, United States

Nestled in the highly coveted Hay Beach enclave of Shelter Island, 43 Gardiners Bay Drive is a grand, ˜ 6,100-square-foot coastal estate that redefines luxury through the lens of effortless living. Set on a sprawling 0.92-acre parcel with captivating winter water views of Gardiners Bay, this masterfully designed home offers a seamless daily rhythm, beginning in the light-filled foyer where exquisite millwork meets glass doors that open to the expansive grounds. Designed for both high-end entertaining and absolute ease, the flowing main level connects a stately firelit living room to a magnificent chef's kitchen—complete with a professional cooktop, a walk-in pantry, and dual dishwashers for effortless cleanup—before transitioning outside to a resort-style pool featuring an electric safety cover and direct cabana-bath access. A sanctuary of personal wellness, the second floor boasts a marble-clad primary suite with a private water-view office overlooking the bay, alongside three generous guest rooms and two laundry rooms configured for ultimate convenience. Below, the fully finished lower level serves as a private wellness and entertainment pavilion, featuring a home gym, media room, and a temperature-controlled wine cellar, balanced by an abundant bulk-provisioning storage room and an attached garage for your water toys. Situated just steps from the pristine sands of Menhaden Lane Beach and moments from the island’s premier marinas, boutiques, and acclaimed dining, this estate offers a turnkey, worry-free island lifestyle where every modern luxury is already perfectly in place.

Perched along the pristine shoreline of Sag Harbor Bay, this newly constructed waterfront estate offers one of the most extraordinary settings in the Hamptons. Situated on 1.7 private acres surrounded by a protected tidal estuary, the property delivers uninterrupted panoramic water views, exceptional privacy, and a seamless connection to nature. Spanning over 6,000+/- square feet across three finished levels with elevator access throughout, the residence features six beautifully appointed bedroom suites designed to maximize light, space, and the breathtaking surroundings. The main level primary suite is a true retreat, complete with floor to ceiling glass walls and a private covered terrace showcasing spectacular sunrise to sunset vistas with no neighboring homes in sight. Three additional guest suites are also located on this level. The upper level reveals the home's most dramatic living spaces, where soaring open concept interiors are framed by expansive walls of glass and oversized sliding doors that create a seamless indoor-outdoor lifestyle experience. The living room, dining area, and gourmet chef's kitchen all overlook the stunning bayfront scenery. Thoughtfully curated finishes include exquisite Italian stonework selected to complement the natural landscape, anchored by a statement Officine Gullo range. Designed for both relaxation and entertaining, the outdoor living spaces feature expansive terraces, an elevated pool, sun drenched lounging areas, and covered waterfront dining. The garden level offers two additional family suites, a media and recreation lounge, and a waterfront fitness studio complete with a six person barrel sauna and cold plunge. Beautifully landscaped grounds lead to a private walkway and bayfront beach, where a secluded picnic area creates the perfect setting for peaceful waterfront afternoons. Rarely does a property combine architectural sophistication, resort level amenities, and such an unparalleled natural setting in one offering. A truly exceptional Hamptons waterfront estate.

Perched along the pristine shoreline of Sag Harbor Bay, this newly constructed waterfront estate offers one of the most extraordinary settings in the Hamptons. Situated on 1.7 private acres surrounded by a protected tidal estuary, the property delivers uninterrupted panoramic water views, exceptional privacy, and a seamless connection to nature. Spanning over 6,000+/- square feet across three finished levels with elevator access throughout, the residence features six beautifully appointed bedroom suites designed to maximize light, space, and the breathtaking surroundings. The main level primary suite is a true retreat, complete with floor to ceiling glass walls and a private covered terrace showcasing spectacular sunrise to sunset vistas with no neighboring homes in sight. Three additional guest suites are also located on this level. The upper level reveals the home's most dramatic living spaces, where soaring open concept interiors are framed by expansive walls of glass and oversized sliding doors that create a seamless indoor-outdoor lifestyle experience. The living room, dining area, and gourmet chef's kitchen all overlook the stunning bayfront scenery. Thoughtfully curated finishes include exquisite Italian stonework selected to complement the natural landscape, anchored by a statement Officine Gullo range. Designed for both relaxation and entertaining, the outdoor living spaces feature expansive terraces, an elevated pool, sun drenched lounging areas, and covered waterfront dining. The garden level offers two additional family suites, a media and recreation lounge, and a waterfront fitness studio complete with a six person barrel sauna and cold plunge. Beautifully landscaped grounds lead to a private walkway and bayfront beach, where a secluded picnic area creates the perfect setting for peaceful waterfront afternoons. Rarely does a property combine architectural sophistication, resort level amenities, and such an unparalleled natural setting in one offering. A truly exceptional Hamptons waterfront estate.

Perched along the pristine shoreline of Sag Harbor Bay, this newly constructed waterfront estate offers one of the most extraordinary settings in the Hamptons. Situated on 1.7 private acres surrounded by a protected tidal estuary, the property delivers uninterrupted panoramic water views, exceptional privacy, and a seamless connection to nature.nnSpanning over 6,000+/- square feet across three finished levels with elevator access throughout, the residence features six beautifully appointed bedroom suites designed to maximize light, space, and the breathtaking surroundings. The main level primary suite is a true retreat, complete with floor to ceiling glass walls and a private covered terrace showcasing spectacular sunrise-to-sunset vistas with no neighboring homes in sight. Three additional guest suites are also located on this level.nnThe upper level reveals the homes most dramatic living spaces, where soaring open concept interiors are framed by expansive walls of glass and oversized sliding doors that create a seamless indoor outdoor lifestyle experience. The living room, dining area, and gourmet chefs kitchen all overlook the stunning bayfront scenery. Thoughtfully curated finishes include exquisite Italian stonework selected to complement the natural landscape, anchored by a statement Officine Gullo range.nnDesigned for both relaxation and entertaining, the outdoor living spaces feature expansive terraces, an elevated pool, sun drenched lounging areas, and covered waterfront dining. The garden level offers two additional family suites, a media and recreation lounge, and a waterfront fitness studio complete with a six-person barrel sauna and cold plunge.nnBeautifully landscaped grounds lead to a private walkway and bayfront beach, where a secluded picnic area creates the perfect setting for peaceful waterfront afternoons. Rarely does a property combine architectural sophistication, resort level amenities, and such an unparalleled natural setting in one offering. A truly exceptional Hamptons waterfront estate.

Rare opportunity to own a charming early-1900s Victorian farmhouse in the historic Heights. Set on a quiet road, this inviting home features an extra-large yard perfect for entertaining and a welcoming wraparound porch ideal for relaxing summer evenings. Inside, the home boasts a spacious living room with a wood-burning fireplace, a gracious parlor, formal dining room, and a first-floor bedroom with a full bath. Upstairs are two additional bedrooms and another full bath. A full basement provides ample storage and utility space. Just a stone’s throw from downtown shopping, restaurants, and all that the Heights has to offer, this is a rare find in one of Shelter Island’s most sought-after neighborhoods.

Located in the heart of Orient Village, across the street from the Yacht Club and near all Village amenities, this fully updated nineteenth-century home features a wrap-around front porch, original hardwood floors, three bedrooms, first & second floor full baths, and a large eat-in kitchen with original pantry. The home has a front and rear staircase and a glass pocket door between the living room and formal dining room. A pathway leads through the rear garden to a two-story accessory structure of approximately 1,714 square feet, currently used as an artist's studio and art storage. The grounds are professionally landscaped with mature plantings, a dining patio, and multiple seating areas. Rarely does a property this unique come to market in Orient Village, the crown jewel of the North Fork.

Beautifully updated & fully renovated in 2020, Arts & Crafts style home in the heart of Orient Village, one block from Orient Harbor, walking distance to post office, country store & all village amenities. Open concept dining/living room with large wood burning fireplace. Updated gourmet kitchen with Thermador 6 burner/griddle stove, Subzero refrigerator, Bosch dishwasher, & wine cooler. Enclosed front porch sunroom. Second floor master bedroom with large balcony overlooking the garden with ensuite bath – 2 sinks, free-standing tub & walk-in shower. Two additional bedrooms and full bath with tub and front-loading washer/dryer. Fenced yard, outdoor shower, backyard deck & lower patio for outdoor dining & entertaining. Professionally landscaped with mature trees and flower beds. Detached 1-car garage.

Set in the wonderful North Fork beach community of Summit Estates, this spacious 3 bedroom, 2-bath cedar shake expanded ranch is ideal with its single-story living design and large yard ~ perfect for a pool and poolhouse. The Community beach, park, and dock are down an elegant private lane to a community parking lot and a magical paved trail. So handy to easily transport your beach and boat equipment from car to beach and boat! Close to Island’s End Golf Course, wineries, and the transportation hub and shopping/dining in the historic seaport Village of Greenport. A lovely North Fork retreat!

This storybook circa 1858 cottage captures the very essence of North Fork living: cozy, charming, and effortlessly inviting. Rich in history and timeless appeal, this beautifully preserved home blends the simplicity of a bygone era with thoughtful modern updates, creating a warm and welcoming retreat. Inside, random-width wide plank flooring adds authentic character throughout. The first floor offers a spacious primary bedroom, a second bedroom or home office, an inviting living room, formal dining room, and an eat-in kitchen with a convenient laundry area. Upstairs, two additional bedrooms and a half bath provide comfortable accommodations. Architectural details enhance the home's enduring charm, from the welcoming semi-wraparound covered front porch to the side deck with a new retractable awning overlooking beautifully landscaped gardens. A pergola with a slate patio creates the perfect setting for outdoor dining, entertaining, or simply relaxing on a summer evening. Adding to the property's appeal is a detached 2-car garage and a delightful artist's or hobby studio, complete with its own pergola-covered sitting area nestled among lush gardens. Privately tucked behind a classic white picket fence, the beautifully landscaped .5-acre property is an exceptional outdoor sanctuary. The backyard features a heated free-form Gunite pool with a cascading waterfall, a pool shed with deck, two additional storage sheds, mature trees, and an abundance of seasonal flowering plantings, creating a peaceful and private oasis. Ideally located just minutes from pristine beaches, golf courses, marinas, renowned wineries and breweries, county parks, farm stands, Hampton Jitney and popular local eateries. This special property also enjoys close proximity to Historic Greenport, where waterfront dining, boutique shopping, and galleries await. The backyard abuts a nature preserve that leads to Marion Lake County Park. Nothing can be built behind it. Whether you're enjoying a quiet morning coffee on the porch, spending the afternoon poolside, or entertaining friends after a day at the beach, this one-of-a-kind North Fork treasure offers the perfect blend of historic character, modern comfort, and relaxed coastal living.

Introducing an exceptional opportunity to own a truly turnkey, fully restored farmhouse-style two-family home in a prime Greenport Village location. 430 First Street features two meticulously updated residences, each offering three bedrooms, one full bathroom, and thoughtfully designed living spaces. The upper-level residence encompasses approximately 1,000 square feet and features soaring vaulted ceilings with decorative cross beams and an open-concept Great Room seamlessly connecting the kitchen, dining, and living areas. Three generously sized bedrooms, a full bathroom, and an in-unit washer and dryer complete the space. The main-level residence offers a similar layout with approximately 1,300 square feet of living space. Highlights include three bedrooms, one full bathroom, a spacious kitchen with vaulted ceilings, and an additional 300 square feet of living area, providing added flexibility and room to spread out. Outside, the property is equally impressive, with meticulously maintained landscaping, a newly installed crushed-stone driveway with Belgian block edging, a large rear lawn, full irrigation, and a charming front porch. A substantial 600-square-foot, two-car garage and additional storage shed further enhance the property's functionality. Whether you're an investor seeking a ready-made income-producing property or an end user looking to offset carrying costs with rental income, 430 First Street presents a compelling opportunity in the heart of Greenport Village. Located just two blocks from Greenport's vibrant business district, the property offers convenient access to public transportation, shops, restaurants, grocery stores, local farm stands, parks, and beaches—all while providing the space, condition, and versatility that make this a truly special offering.

Located in the desirable Harborview area of Shelter Island, this modern farmhouse blends luxury, comfort, and coastal living. Just 0.2 miles from a private waterfront association, enjoy easy access to kayaking and the beach. Set on a beautifully landscaped half acre, the home is designed for seamless indoor-outdoor living. The open-concept interior is flooded with natural light, featuring a chef’s kitchen that flows effortlessly to the dining and living areas, highlighting views of the backyard oasis. Outside, relax in the heated pool, outdoor shower, or firepit lounge, or entertain on the spacious deck with retractable awning and covered dining area. With five generous bedrooms, including primary suites on both the first and second floors, the home accommodates guests in style. The upstairs suite features a gas fireplace and covered balcony. The fully finished lower level includes a media room with theater seating, a versatile den or gym with yard access, and a fifth bedroom with a large hall bath. Step inside and start enjoying the best of Shelter Island living.

Experience the pinnacle of refined living in this completely reimagined home, boasting a comprehensive renovation and redesign led by a professional interior designer. Every square inch has been thoughtfully curated, starting with the custom front door featuring openable screened sidelights that welcome you inside. Premium oak hardwood flooring flows seamlessly throughout the main living areas, grounding the home in natural warmth and elegance. The heart of the home, the great room and large kitchen, is an entertainer's dream, featuring gas fireplace, a dry bar with a wine fridge, premium lighting and plumbing fixtures, quartz countertops and custom window treatments including blinds and valances. First floor also includes a light filled den and separate office space for working at home. Retreat to the spectacular owner’s suite, a true sanctuary defined by architectural ceilings with shiplap details and a custom walk-in closet. The en-suite bathroom is clad in Italian marble and featuring premium fixtures. Indulge in the luxury of radiant floor heating—which extends into the large, curbless spa shower with its sleek infinity drain. Your guests are treated to equal luxury; guest baths feature premium fixtures and their own radiant floor heating. The guest bedrooms offer cozy carpeting and custom woodworking with the twin room featuring blackout and light-filtering shades for perfect rest. Behind the walls, the home is just as impressive. A whole-house water softening and purification system, smart irrigation system, and 2-zone heat/AC with smart thermostats ensure comfort and peace of mind. This is more than a renovation; it is a complete lifestyle upgrade. Located close to the heart of downtown Greenport Village and its bayfront beaches and transportation hub.

Welcome to 550 Madison Avenue in Greenport, a thoughtfully designed New Construction farmhouse that feels comfortable from the moment you arrive. The covered front porch is more than an architectural detail. There is actually room for a chair and side table, creating the perfect spot for a quiet morning coffee. Inside, wide 6-inch oak floors connect the bright, open living spaces. The powder room is conveniently located near the front entrance, but it is tucked far enough away from the open living room, dining area, and kitchen to give everyone a little privacy when the house is full. The custom kitchen design brings together the features buyers keep asking for, including a paneled refrigerator, a full pantry closet, open shelving, generous cabinetry, and a kitchen sink positioned beneath a window overlooking the backyard. Even doing the dishes comes with a view of the established maple trees. A full glass slider in the dining area fills the back of the home with natural light and creates an easy connection to the outdoor entertaining spaces and grill. The backyard views can also be enjoyed from the living room, making the surrounding landscape feel like part of the interior design. Upstairs, the primary bedroom features a peaceful en-suite bathroom with distinctive tile flooring and calm, carefully selected finishes. Even the first-floor powder room has beautiful wallpaper, adding personality and making this New Construction home feel intentional rather than predictable. The fully fenced backyard is surrounded by established maple trees, creating a quiet and private setting that feels like a hidden corner of Greenport. The newly installed stone patio includes an outdoor cushioned conversation area, a separate outdoor dining patio, and a dedicated fire pit for evenings under the trees. There is also room to explore the possibility of adding a pool without making the yard feel crowded. The location brings the North Fork lifestyle within easy reach. The Greenport LIRR station and Hampton Jitney stop are approximately half a mile away for convenient transportation to New York City. Aldo’s Coffee is about a three-minute bike ride or a ten-minute walk, with Greenport Village shops, restaurants, waterfront destinations, and local beaches all close enough to enjoy without always getting back into the car. New Construction, a custom kitchen, paneled appliances, wide oak floors, en-suite bathrooms, a fenced backyard, mature trees, outdoor entertaining spaces, and easy access to Greenport Village. This might be the one you have been waiting for. You really need to come see it. In the evening it sparks with fireflies to capture summer vibes in Greenport Village.

Opportunity knocks! This rare farmhouse style cottage rests on an expansive double lot on the edge of Greenport Village and is prime to be revamped. Featuring 1700sqft of interior space, a large block foundation with full basement throughout most of the footprint, a 12x22 detached garage and a yard that will allow your imagination to run wild. Walk into town, walk to 5th and 6th street beaches and easy access to all that the North Fork has to offer.

Level .919-acre lot in Hillcrest Estates, Orient, NY. Beautiful site with electric and natural gas in the street. Close to Orient State Park, Orient Village, Truman’s Beach, Sound and Bay Beaches. A short drive to Greenport Village for shopping and restaurants.