luxury houses for sale Herkimer County, United States

Tojenka is a combination of historic character, refined upgrades and exceptional waterfront privacy. Set on 3.4 acres with approximately 625' of almost level shoreline on a small peninsula, the property enjoys one of the most coveted settings within the region, with sweeping lake views and a true sense of Adirondack seclusion. Thoughtfully updated with a careful eye toward preserving its original charm, the residence blends Victorian Elegance with rustic Adirondack warmth. Recent improvements include new heating and cooling systems, added insulation, selected electrical and plumbing updates and a beautifully integrated 25' X 33' primary suite featuring a service kitchen, laundry and luxurious bath to go along with the bedroom with fireplace. The addition feels seamless, honoring the architecture of the home while creating a private retreat of remarkable scale and comfort. A newer, 4 car garage has 10' doors to accommodate excellent storage of cars, truck and boats.

Enjoy summers on Fourth Lake in your own classic Adirondack cottage, with a spacious dock and a boathouse transformed into a welcoming waterside sitting area. Set on 1.37 wooded acres with 36 feet of waterfront, this well-maintained property offers a peaceful setting and boating access to the Fulton Chain from Old Forge to Inlet. The converted boathouse offers a comfortable gathering space while still providing storage for small boats and lake gear. Unwind on the cottage's screened porch while taking in sunset views. Inside, an eat-in kitchen, updated first-floor bathroom, and living room with wood floors and a beautiful stone wood-burning fireplace create a welcoming place to return to. Upstairs, three Adirondack-style bedrooms capture the charm of an earlier era. A quarter-mile driveway meanders through the woods to this inviting summer getaway.

There's waterfront property, and then there's living right at the water's edge. Near the First Lake end of the Narrows, this beautifully updated Colonial offers views of First Lake, 90 feet of waterfrontage, a dock, and a little sandy beach. Just steps from the water, its spacious deck is a front-row seat to boats passing through the Narrows. Built in 1950, before today's Adirondack Park shoreline setback regulations, this home enjoys an extraordinary waterfront setting that cannot be recreated with new construction under current setback requirements. While its location reflects an earlier era of Adirondack living, the house tells a much more recent story of extensive improvements and thoughtful care. Since purchasing the property in 2018, the sellers have made substantial investments, including a new roof, added mudroom, quarter-log siding, Andersen windows, exterior doors, and updated waterfront decking. The original first-floor floors were professionally refinished, new flooring was installed upstairs in 2024, the living room's stone fireplace was renovated in 2022, and lighting was updated throughout. A newer hot water heater and a new furnace and central air conditioning installed in September 2025 bring modern comfort to this year-round home. Offering 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths, and 1,560 square feet, the home blends classic Adirondack character with modern comforts. Large waterfront windows bring the scenery indoors, while the deck, dock, and sandy shoreline invite you outside to enjoy it. Hollywood Hills also features a separate private property owners association beach on First Lake, with fee-based boat launch and docking options available through the association. An irreplaceable waterfront setting from an earlier era of Adirondack living, with a home thoughtfully updated for today and ready for its next chapter.

Tucked beneath the trees in historic Okara Lakes, 'Perry's Place' is a distinctive 1921 seasonal camp with more than a century of Adirondack history behind it. Featured in Adirondack Life: At Home in the Adirondacks 2022, Rustic Style, the property was identified as a Magonigle-designed camp and highlighted for its striking architecture, original character, and connection to the surrounding woods. Okara Lakes traces its beginnings to 1920, when the de Camp family began developing the area through Ga-Wan-Ka as a private Adirondack vacation community. Noted architect H. Van Buren Magonigle helped shape its early design vision, which included Japanese-inspired cottages with distinctive rooflines. The beginnings of this community of private camps are now commemorated by a William G. Pomeroy Foundation historic marker. Set on a .77 wooded acre lot, Perry's Place offers 888 sq. ft., 3 bedrooms, and 1 bath. Inside, hardwood floors, original details throughout, and a fireplace at the heart of the living space preserve the unmistakable feel of an early Adirondack camp. The enclosed porch with new windows offers a comfortable place to relax among the trees, while Lake Tekeni is just a short walk from the backyard. A detached shed/bunkhouse offers useful extra space and adds to the camp's character. Updates over the years include a newer metal roof, cedar-shake exterior work, porch and pier repairs, a bathroom renovation in 2018, bunkhouse roof replacement in 2015, a septic system installed in 2021, and fireplace and hearth repairs completed through March 2025. Perry's Place is not a modern recreation of Adirondack camp life. It is an authentic piece of Okara Lakes history, with distinctive architecture, a peaceful wooded setting, Lake Tekeni close by, and a story that began more than 100 years ago. 148 Onekio Road is ready for its next chapter.

This year round log home has been decorated with Adirondack antiques, completely equipped and is ready for you to move in. If you are looking for a rental when you aren't there, it has a good rental history. The floorplan includes a chef's kitchen with large island and seating, a 6 burner propane stove, 2 sinks, plenty of cupboards and drawers and granite countertops. There is a spacious dining area plus a living room with views into the woods. Three sets of French doors including one from the primary ensuite lead out to an expansive, partially covered deck Upstairs are two beautifully appointed ensuites with a loft sitting area above the living room. The other portion of the downstairs could be a recreation or TV room. The high ceilings and amount of space lends itself to finishing. There is already frames another bedroom and partially plumbed bathroom. Another set of French doors leads to the outside and the large yard. The heat is propane hot air and full air conditioning. All decorations and furnishings are include at this price. A full list is available. Lake rights to swim and kayak at Big Moose Lake is right down the road. The Big Moose Lake Marina is very nearby and you can conveniently rent a dock space for your boat and explore the 1200 acre Big Moose Lake.

This year round, log chalet is located on a protected cove with easy access to the mainstream of Fourth Lake of the Fulton Chain of Lakes. There is abundant wildlife and bird activity including loons, ducks, mergansers on the water. A gentle slope leads to a long dock that sits on the water and offers plenty of docking space for boats, swimming and there is even a slide for the kids. The house features a window wall looking out at the water, with a combined living/dining room and an open kitchen. On the main floor is one bedroom and a full bath. Steps lead up to a loft bedroom with its own outdoor balcony. On the lower, walk out level is another bedroom, TV or recreation room and another bathroom with shower. The laundry is located downstairs in the utility, storage room. Walk out to the lawn from here and right to the waterfront for easy access. A shed give more storage room. There is a generator, newer leach field, propane fired hot water heat and a 200 amp electrical entrance with CBs. This is a year round waterfront home with access from a year round, town maintained road. A small shed sits away from the house for more storage.

Tucked along a peaceful bay on Fourth Lake, this 3.89-acre property offers 212 feet of waterfront in a sheltered setting ideal for kayaking, paddleboarding, and quiet days by the water, while still providing easy access to the main lake. The property includes a 1075-square-foot log cabin with a full basement, open half-story, and porch overlooking the bay, along with a separate 744-square-foot guest cottage with an open floor plan. Both structures have been cleaned out and are ready for renovation, offering a wonderful starting point for creating a private, year-round Adirondack retreat. Conveniently located between Old Forge and Inlet, adjacent to the Petrie Road neighborhood and near state land.

Two almost identical ranch style cottages sit on 75' of open frontage on Fourth Lake of the Fulton Chain of Lakes. Each cottage is 800 sq. ft including 3 bedrooms, a great room and bathroom with shower and a full covered porch. Situated on the north shore, there are great views and a southern exposure for warm sunny days of activities. There is seasonal access on Teowana Road off of Route 28. This would make a perfect multi family compound or a twin rental situation. Both have nice, 9' X 20' covered front porches for sitting or having an outdoor meal. There is a shared septic and well and a slip and dock for sharing as well. A barn behind them is 20 X 22 and needs attention. Some of the nice features include a wood burning fireplace in the each, built in bureaus in the bedrooms, new laminate flooring in one and carpet in the other. One has a shingle roof, the other is metal. Both have oil fired hot air heaters for cool evenings and mornings.

Located on the sought after "Golden Mile" just minutes from the hamlet of Old Forge, this spacious, year round waterfront home offers a perfect blend of privacy, comfort and convenience. Situated on South Shore Acres road, a quiet, dead end, town maintained roadway, this property enjoys a peaceful setting with protected wooded views across the road that helps preserve the natural surroundings. Designed for gathering and entertaining, the home features 5 bedrooms, and 4 full baths, along with multiple inviting spaces to relax and unwind. Enjoy the expansive enclosed porch overlooking the water with hot tub, an eat-in kitchen, recreation room, inviting living room with fireplace and a recreation room off the kitchen. On the lower level is a bedroom, additional space for movie nights, an exercise room and office. Step outside to your dock on First Lake and enjoy easy access to boating, kayaking, fishing and exploring the Fulton Chain of Lakes. Whether heading out for a sunset cruise or spending the day on the water, this property offers an ideal spot to return to. Nearby is year round recreation: golf course, ski opportunities, snowmobiling, hiking and bike trails and the local attraction, "Enchanted Forest Water Safari". Whether you are looking for a full time residence or an Adirondack getaway, this property offers the opportunity to experience all four seasons in of the region's most desirable waterfront locations.

A reimagined 1880s toll booth on 55+ private acres with stream frontage, wooded trails, and rolling Mohawk Valley views — where one-of-a-kind character meets serious land, at a fraction of Hudson Valley prices. Evermore Glen is a rare pairing: a cottage with a story you won't find anywhere else, set on over 55 acres of diverse, usable land. The home began its life as the local toll booth in 1880 and has been thoughtfully reimagined into an intimate, character-rich retreat, the kind of place that feels like it was always meant to be here, tucked into this hillside along a sparkling stream. Inside, every detail has soul. Original wide-plank floors carry the patina of nearly 150 years. A fireplace that anchors the main living space. The primary bedroom's vaulted ceiling and exposed beams open the room skyward, while the second floor offers a storybook sitting area perfect for reading, writing, or working remotely. Thoughtful updates in 2007 added modern comfort without disturbing the character — this is a home that wraps around you. Then step outside and the scale shifts entirely. Over 55 acres of rolling meadow, mature hardwood forest, ATV and hiking trails, and a stream winding through the property give you room to roam, hunt, fish, snowshoe, or simply breathe. The land invites endless possibility — agriculture, timber, hunting, a future second structure, or simply the peace of knowing it's all yours. And the toll booth cottage gives you a truly unique home from day one. Just a short drive from historic Cooperstown, the Baseball Hall of Fame, Otsego Lake, and the shops, dining, and cultural attractions of the Mohawk Valley. The perfect marriage of acreage and a home unlike any other.

Ramblers Lodge is a unique Fourth Lake property rich in Adirondack character and the charm of a historic seasonal lodge. The four-bedroom main lodge features an updated kitchen, a beautiful window-lined room filled with natural light, and an expansive front porch made for summer days on the lake. Stairs and a walkway lead to the waterfront, where the historic boathouse--predating Adirondack Park Agency regulations--includes a three-bedroom apartment above. An expansive dock and spacious waterfront deck overlook a protected, sandy-bottom swimming area. A bright and airy two-bedroom apartment is attached to the rear of the lodge, while the back of the property includes a laundry building, charming studio cottage, and a second-story one-bedroom apartment overlooking the backyard and forest--ideal for an on-site manager. With its distinctive architecture, multiple accommodations, and exceptional waterfront spaces, Ramblers Lodge offers a rare opportunity to own a piece of Fourth Lake history.

Experience serene lake living in this beautiful 3-bedroom, 2-bath home featuring an all-wood interior that brings warmth and natural elegance throughout. The spacious living room boasts a striking stone fireplace, perfect for cozy evenings, and a dramatic window wall that floods the space with natural light while offering breathtaking views of the lake. Step outside to the expansive wraparound deck, an ideal spot for entertaining guests or enjoying meals outdoors while soaking in the tranquil lakefront scenery. The property also includes private guest quarters above the garage—perfect for visitors or extra family space. Whether relaxing inside or embracing outdoor living, this home blends rustic charm with modern comfort for the ultimate lakeside lifestyle. The furnishings and boat and motor included in the price.

Located just minutes from the village of Old Forge, this spacious year-round home offers 4 bedrooms, 3 baths, and an oversized heated two-car garage. The exceptionally large primary bedroom offers plenty of room to relax and ample storage, while a smaller bedroom, currently used for storage, could easily serve as a home office, bunk room, or additional guest space. The inviting eat-in kitchen features a sliding glass door leading to a slate patio and overlooks the beautiful, level backyard. Outdoor living is a highlight, with a screened-in front porch. The scenic backyard also offers a fire pit area, wood and storage sheds, and convenient access to a main-floor bathroom. Freshly painted throughout, the home also includes attractive furniture and a generator, making it a comfortable and well-equipped Adirondack retreat.

Located on 192 feet of frontage on picturesque Big Moose Lake, this one-level, 3-bedroom, 2-bath home presents a wonderful opportunity to create your own Adirondack retreat on a total of 4.5 acres. The spacious living room features a fireplace, while a bright den is flanked by two screened porches. A generous front porch spans the front of the home and overlooks the level lawn, sandy beach, and lake. Set on a quiet lake with convenient year-round access, the property is just 11 minutes from the village of Eagle Bay. Additional features include plenty of parking, a large garage with a workbench, a removable dock, hot tub, and some furnishings. The waterfront parcel consists of 1.4 acres, with an additional 3.1-acre parcel behind the home included in the offering, providing added privacy and future possibilities.

This home has so many possibilities. It is currently used as a short term rental property with a three bedroom, 2 bath unit with 2010 sq. ft. and a fully equipped studio apart with separate entrance. The basement level is walk out and is partially finished and ready to be completed for more living space. The residence has town water and a private septic. A two car, oversized garage has abundant room for two cars and a workshop or storage. This home has been renovated over the last 3 years. The primary bedroom is an ensuite and there is a bath with soaking tub for the other two bedrooms. Come and take a look at this property on a 1.6 acre corner lot. It is close to town and near the snowmobile trail 6 where you can ride all over the Adirondacks and beyond. The yard features a nice grassy area for relaxing with trees surround it for privacy.

Exclusive Post-and-Beam Retreat on Pristine Honnedaga Lake Experience unparalleled serenity with this stunning post-and-beam chalet and charming guest cottage, offering sweeping views of Honnedaga Lake—one of the most pristine, untouched bodies of water in the Adirondacks. The Main Residence & Guest Cottage Designed for both grand entertaining and cozy mountain evenings, the main residence centers around a spectacular Great Room featuring a towering two-story stone fireplace and a majestic window wall that frames the breathtaking natural surroundings. The main floor thoughtfully includes four bedrooms and two full baths, while the upper level provides a versatile loft and dedicated office space. Your visitors will find comfort and privacy in the accompanying guest cottage, complete with its own living area, bedroom space, and a second beautiful stone fireplace. Outside, expansive decks and a classic screened-in porch offer the perfect vantage points to savor cool mountain breezes and sweeping lake views. The Adirondack League Club Lifestyle Situated within the storied Adirondack League Club (ALC)—a private, ecologically mindful organization established in the late 1800s—this property offers more than just a home; it offers an extraordinary wilderness lifestyle. The ALC was founded with a deep commitment to natural preservation, sustainable forestry, and maintaining the region's exceptional water purity. Membership grants you exclusive access to 50,000 acres of preserved woods and waters, along with three distinct clubhouses located on three different lakes. Honnedaga’s own "Forest Lodge" serves as a vibrant hub during the summer months, offering: Full dining facilities and a general store A classic library Tennis and pickleball courts A full calendar of entertainment and community activities Important Ownership Details Please note: Purchasing this remarkable property is a unique opportunity that requires approved membership in the Adirondack League Club. To preserve the club's traditional structure, all purchases are cash-only (no mortgages permitted), and standard initiation fees apply.

Charming 3-unit apartment building, year-round investment commercial building located in the center of town, on the bustling Main St of Old Forge, NY. This fully renovated property features three spacious 1 bedroom apartments. With all furnishings included, this turn-key investment is ready for immediate occupancy. Two units are rented as Air BnBs and the 3rd unit has a year lease tenant. Rental permits are in place. The property offers a unique opportunity to own a prime piece of real estate in a highly desirable location in town. Priced at $499,000.