luxury houses for sale Sag Harbor, United States

Two houses positioned just one block from Main Streets' American Hotel and the famous Sag Harbor Superyacht docks. 25 Rector Street offers an exceptionally rare and legal multi-family configuration. Comprising two character-rich structures-The Whaler's Cottage and The Artist's Retreat-the property benefits from a highly coveted, pre-existing non-conforming status, making it an incredibly unique find in the heart of Sag Harbor Village. Steeped in heritage, the one and a half bedroom Whaler's Cottage anchors the eastern portion of the property and dates back to the mid-1800s as a whaling industry supply building. Directly adjacent on the western side sits the one bedroom Artist's Retreat, which was beautifully renovated in 2016 and features an enchanting studio-turned-bedroom. A massive 1500 sq ft brick patio flows from the kitchen's French doors, and offers a spacious finished area for outdoor dining and relaxation. The property has a rich artistic legacy, which is only matched by its incredible future potential. Because the property is not on the list of the Village's inventory of historically significant structures, it allows more freedom to make the house your own. For those seeking multi-generational living, an irreplaceable location, and unrepeatable history- this is a once-in-a-generation opportunity.

Conveniently located 5 BR, 5 Bath sun filled traditional home in Sag Harbor Village perched on a hill is a quick stroll, bike ride or even quicker two minute drive to downtown Sag Harbor and bay beaches. Centrally located, 18 Cuffee Drive is a ten minute drive to East Hampton and Bridgehampton by car. The private backyard oasis features a heated gunite pool and hot tub, patio and deck areas. This 4300 square foot home on .5 acre boosts two floors with an additional large finished lower level. Gracious double height entry leads to spacious, open kitchen with oversized center island and great room with vaulted ceilings, beautiful skylights, flat screen TV and French doors. In addition, there is a first floor guest bedroom, bath, sitting area, and laundry room. On the second level, a primary bedroom overlooks the pool and gardens with ensuite bathroom, 2 guest bedrooms and 2 baths (one ensuite) provide ample quarters for entertaining guests. The finished lower level is 1100 sq. ft. with oversized windows, natural light, oversized sectional sofa, flat screen TV/cable, workout room with cardio equipment (elliptical machine, treadmill, recumbent bike), foosball and ping pong table, electronic keyboard, 5th guest bedroom and bath, and playroom. Additionally, the house provides ample parking, whole house filtered water system, and a multi-zoned heating and air conditioning system. Recently renovated and updated.

On coveted Glover Street in the Village of Sag Harbor, first time offering historic 3 bedroom, 3 bathroom house in mint condition. Rich in warmth and character, the 3,000+/- sq. ft. home features a generous living room with original exposed beams and fireplace. Spacious dining room giving to the outdoors/garden, an eat in kitchen, an ample laundry room, and a first floor bedroom/den plus bathroom. Upstairs, the expansive primary suite is paired with an adjoining sitting room and second bedroom. Outside, a bluestone patio with awning is surrounded by exquisite landscaping and specimen trees, while the detached garage and private driveway offers additional parking convenience in Sag Harbor Village. Plus, room for pool.

**Now offered at $2,495,000**, this beautifully renovated, **turnkey four-bedroom** village home represents one of the best values on Sag Harbor's coveted Captain's Row. Overlooking picturesque Otter Pond, **356 Main Street** offers a rare combination of historic character, water views, modern upgrades, approved expansion potential, and an exceptional location just moments from Sag Harbor Village's renowned restaurants, marinas, boutiques, and waterfront. Originally dating to the 1850s as the home of Austin Morris, the residence has been extensively renovated while carefully preserving the timeless architectural charm that defines this historic neighborhood. Significant improvements include updated mechanical systems, central air conditioning, beautifully renovated bathrooms, an updated kitchen with premium appliances, restored original antique wood floors, and numerous thoughtful upgrades throughout, creating a home that is truly move-in ready while maintaining its authentic historic character. Filled with natural light, the home offers multiple entertaining spaces, a spacious chef's kitchen, and a versatile first-floor TV room with an adjacent full bathroom that is currently being offered as the home's fourth bedroom, providing ideal flexibility for guests, a home office, or a primary suite on the main level. Upstairs, the primary bedroom enjoys tranquil views across Otter Pond, while two additional guest bedrooms overlook the property's mature landscaping and gardens. A finished lower level provides valuable bonus space for a media room, fitness area, playroom, or home office. What truly distinguishes this property is that, unlike many historic village homes requiring extensive renovation, **356 Main Street** combines the convenience of a fully updated, turnkey residence with outstanding future upside. Approved plans are already in place for a new I/A septic system supporting a legal four-bedroom residence, along with approvals from both the Board of Health and the Architectural Review Board for an 18' x 10' swimming pool-entitlements that are increasingly difficult to obtain within the Village of Sag Harbor. These approvals provide a future owner with a straightforward path to further enhance both the property's lifestyle appeal and long-term value. Outside, a welcoming front porch, beautifully landscaped grounds, and multiple outdoor entertaining areas create a quintessential Hamptons setting, all framed by peaceful views over Otter Pond. With historic charm, modern turnkey living, water views, approved pool and septic plans, flexible four-bedroom accommodations, and one of Sag Harbor Village's most desirable addresses, **356 Main Street** represents an exceptional opportunity at its new offering price of **$2,495,000**.

Perched at the highest elevation on coveted Cliff Drive in Bay Point, Sag Harbor, this rare opportunity offers sweeping western sunset views over Peconic and Noyack Bays. Renovate, reimagine, or build your own custom waterfront retreat in one of the Hamptons' most desirable waterfront communities. Bay Point captures the charm of classic coastal living with boating, kayaking, and nearby Long Beach, all just minutes from the restaurants, marinas, galleries, and boutiques of Sag Harbor Village. The existing home is offered as-is and awaits a visionary buyer ready to unlock the extraordinary potential of this exceptional setting. Whether restoring the current residence or creating a brand-new coastal masterpiece, this is a rare chance to own a premier sunset-view property in Sag Harbor.

Newly built cedar-shake estate on approximately 2.37 acres overlooking Fresh Pond and Sag Harbor Bay. in coveted North Haven. Offering 8,030± SF of living space, this traditional-style residence blends classic Hamptons architecture with modern scale, just minutes from Sag Harbor Village, marinas, beaches, and dining. The home features 7 bedrooms, 7 full and 2 half bathrooms, with wide-plank white oak floors, tray ceilings, and a wood-burning fireplace anchoring the main living spaces. Walls of sliding glass doors create seamless indoor-outdoor flow and enhance natural light throughout. An eat-in chef's kitchen with premium appliances serves as the heart of the home, complemented by a first-floor office/den. Multiple living and dining areas provide flexibility for everyday living and entertaining. Upstairs includes a beverage center, spacious bedroom suites, and two rear balconies with pond and bay outlooks. The layout is designed for comfort, scale, and easy living. Outdoor amenities include a 20' x 50' heated pool with bluestone patio, covered dining and lounge areas, and a fireplace-centered outdoor living room for year-round enjoyment. A rare highlight is the opportunity to add a 2,500± SF guest house, offering exceptional flexibility for future expansion. A refined North Haven offering with water views, privacy, and timeless design close to Sag Harbor Village.

Newly built modern estate on approximately 3.65 acres overlooking Fresh Pond and Sag Harbor Bay. Located in coveted North Haven, less than one mile from Sag Harbor Village, this 8,960± SF residence offers privacy, scale, and proximity to beaches, marinas, and dining. The home features 8 bedrooms and 8.5 bathrooms, with expansive glass walls, a double-height foyer, and open-concept living areas designed to maximize natural light and water views. The chef's kitchen includes Sub-Zero and Wolf appliances, marble countertops, an oversized island, and a full butler's pantry. Indoor-outdoor living is emphasized with multiple covered porches, terraces, and retractable glass doors. The main level includes a junior primary suite with spa-like bath and sitting room, along with additional living, dining, and service spaces. The upper level offers a water-view primary suite with dual walk-in closets and a luxury bath, plus five ensuite guest bedrooms and a secondary lounge with wet bar and terrace access. Outdoor amenities include a 20' x 50' heated gunite infinity-edge saltwater pool with spa, limestone patios, mahogany terraces, and a 320± SF pool house with kitchenette and firepit. The property also allows space for a future pickleball or padel court. A refined North Haven offering combining modern design, privacy, and convenient access to Sag Harbor Village.

Minutes from the bustle and charm of Sag Harbor Village, set on an exceedingly private and gated acre-plus flag lot with mature hedges, this immaculate 7 bedroom, 6500 square foot traditional checks all the boxes of a quintessential Hamptons summer home with a heated, gunite pool and spa, exceptional outdoor spaces, lined with hydrangeas, built-in BBQ grill kitchen, and an expansive finished lower level. Through the automated gate, a tree-lined approach leads to the handsome, white, shingled traditional with an attached 2-car garage. Adorned with shiplap, the bright, full height foyer creates a dramatic first impression. With lovely indoor and outdoor flow, the open concept floor plan offers a gourmet eat-in kitchen with an adjacent living room with fireplace and sitting area, with two sets of French door leading to the covered porch overlooking the pool area and rear grounds. A formal dining room with passthrough wet bar and wine storage serves the kitchen. A guest bedroom suite, pool full bath, foyer powder bath, expansive mud room, laundry room, and two-car garage completes the main level. Upstairs has a generous primary suite with luxurious bath including a freestanding tub and floating dual vanity. Three spacious en suite guest bedrooms supplement. The finished lower level features a gym, recreation area, and two bedrooms. Unique opportunity to own a turnkey home of excellent quality on a private acre-plus flag lot with a heated, gunite pool and spa and outdoor spaces fit for summer in the Hamptons.

Perfectly appointed this gorgeous modern traditional is a rare offering in the gated waterfront community of West Banks, North Haven just minutes from Sag Harbor Village . Beautifully manicured, and surrounded by a 20 acre reserve this property ensures the utmost privacy and serenity . Newly renovated this residence is sited on 1.27+/- acres and offers 5 bedrooms and 5 and 2 1/2 baths across 5500 +/- sf of beautifully designed living spaces. On arrival, your captivated by soaring double height ceilings and an open floor plan spanning the whole first level. Architecturally designed, the living room and fireplace hearth flow into a perfectly designed chef's kitchen with a large center island, Sub Zero and Wolf appliances and granite counters for entertaining. A gorgeous Great room with southern light cascading in features an oversized jewel fireplace, a full wet bar and entertainment area with a wide expanse of glass Nanawall doors for indoor-outdoor living at its best. Glass panels enclose a dedicated wine room off setting the curated ambiance in this living area. Anchoring this level is a plush primary suite opening out to a covered porch and lush gardens and is the perfect addition. Your second level features a large primary suite with wide views and decking overlooking this stunning property, a designer bath and grand custom closet. The open modern landing flows to an additional guest en-suite and 2 additional bedrooms thoughtfully completing this seamless design. The finished lower-level offers a designated theater area , a fully-equipped professional gym and game area for all to enjoy. Your outdoor living is perfection with a pool house cabana and large studio, full outdoor kitchen with a lynx grill and pizza oven and bar for entertaining. The lush landscape design features beautiful mature plantings and many sun drenched entertaining areas with expansive stone patios. The outdoor lighting is expensive , with Belgian stone led lights for sublime elegance. This gorgeous four sided mirrored salt water infinity pool and spa off sets the entire property and is the perfect addition. The rich beauty of this estate property has been thoughtfully cultivated with timeless charm and care. West Banks offers a newly installed AI system for safe gate monitoring , and a live in caretaker who is there for any and all of your concierge living needs. Surrounding this community is Love Lady nature sanctuary , a 10 acre park with walking paths and trails . Additional amenities are just steps away, and include a private community beach with gorgeous westerly sunsets, deep water dock, and community tennis . A designated property mooring is also part of this wonderful offering . This very special property is just minutes to shops, renowned restaurants and marinas in Sag Harbor Village. Truly a World Class Hampton's property!Listing ID: 931763

Perched along the pristine shoreline of Sag Harbor Bay, this newly constructed waterfront estate offers one of the most extraordinary settings in the Hamptons. Situated on 1.7 private acres surrounded by a protected tidal estuary, the property delivers uninterrupted panoramic water views, exceptional privacy, and a seamless connection to nature. Spanning over 6,000+/- square feet across three finished levels with elevator access throughout, the residence features six beautifully appointed bedroom suites designed to maximize light, space, and the breathtaking surroundings. The main level primary suite is a true retreat, complete with floor to ceiling glass walls and a private covered terrace showcasing spectacular sunrise to sunset vistas with no neighboring homes in sight. Three additional guest suites are also located on this level. The upper level reveals the home's most dramatic living spaces, where soaring open concept interiors are framed by expansive walls of glass and oversized sliding doors that create a seamless indoor-outdoor lifestyle experience. The living room, dining area, and gourmet chef's kitchen all overlook the stunning bayfront scenery. Thoughtfully curated finishes include exquisite Italian stonework selected to complement the natural landscape, anchored by a statement Officine Gullo range. Designed for both relaxation and entertaining, the outdoor living spaces feature expansive terraces, an elevated pool, sun drenched lounging areas, and covered waterfront dining. The garden level offers two additional family suites, a media and recreation lounge, and a waterfront fitness studio complete with a six person barrel sauna and cold plunge. Beautifully landscaped grounds lead to a private walkway and bayfront beach, where a secluded picnic area creates the perfect setting for peaceful waterfront afternoons. Rarely does a property combine architectural sophistication, resort level amenities, and such an unparalleled natural setting in one offering. A truly exceptional Hamptons waterfront estate.

Minutes from the bustle and charm of Sag Harbor Village, set on an exceedingly private and gated acre-plus flag lot with mature hedges, this immaculate 7 bedroom, 6500 square foot traditional checks all the boxes of a quintessential Hamptons summer home with a heated, gunite pool and spa, exceptional outdoor spaces, lined with hydrangeas, built-in BBQ grill kitchen, and an expansive finished lower level. Through the automated gate, a tree-lined approach leads to the handsome, white, shingled traditional with an attached 2-car garage. Adorned with shiplap, the bright, full height foyer creates a dramatic first impression. With lovely indoor and outdoor flow, the open concept floor plan offers a gourmet eat-in kitchen with an adjacent living room with fireplace and sitting area, with two sets of French door leading to the covered porch overlooking the pool area and rear grounds. A formal dining room with passthrough wet bar and wine storage serves the kitchen. A guest bedroom suite, pool full bath, foyer powder bath, expansive mud room, laundry room, and two-car garage completes the main level. Upstairs has a generous primary suite with luxurious bath including a freestanding tub and floating dual vanity. Three spacious en suite guest bedrooms supplement. The finished lower level features a gym, recreation area, and two bedrooms. Unique opportunity to own a turnkey home of excellent quality on a private acre-plus flag lot with a heated, gunite pool and spa and outdoor spaces fit for summer in the Hamptons.

Freshly updated and effortlessly stylish, this Sag Harbor retreat includes coveted private beach access. Sunlight pours through the home, creating a bright, airy atmosphere that feels as inviting in the off-season as it does at the height of summer. The interior offers five well-proportioned bedrooms and 3.5 beautifully finished marble baths, along with a seamless open-concept layout. A modern kitchen flows into the dining and living spaces, ideal for both relaxed everyday living and entertaining. Outdoors, a heated gunite pool with spa anchors the backyard, offering a perfect setting for warm-weather enjoyment. Upstairs, the primary suite features a generous private balcony overlooking the grounds, providing a quiet escape. Just minutes from both Sag Harbor Village and East Hampton, this property strikes the perfect balance between convenience and tranquility.

Huge potential. This turn of the 20th century gem was the residence of a single family through generations since its inception! A Queen Anne style house with its classic front gable and massive covered front porch invokes grandeur of times past as it sits prominently on prestigious Lumber Lane. Much of the original detail has been maintained including millwork, windows, doors, staircase, siding, structure, and the bones of this grand dame appear of high integrity. Collectors often favor a little patina over a flurry of modifications de jour. Such is the case with this roughly 2,100 sf residence, currently configured as two-family home, offering 4 bedrooms, 2 baths, 2 kitchens, 8’8” first floor and 8’4” second floor ceiling heights. In addition, the “1/2 story” attic with four dormers adorned with large leaded glass windows facing in each direction of the compass can stir one’s imagination of what it could become. 119 Lumber Ln located in the heart of Bridgehampton is a short distance from Main St, the LIRR station, numerous beaches, all other Hamptons hamlets, and provides over 5,000 sf of allowable lot coverage: ample space to accommodate expansion of the primary structure as well as various accessory structures and swimming pool/spa, or build a magnificent new home.

Facing due west, magical sunsets and commanding views of Sag Harbor Cove abound from this special 1.1 acre perch at the end of private lane across the way from the former John Steinbeck residence. Minutes from the charms of Main Street, this delightfully tranquil Sag Harbor Village getaway features a circa 1940 3-bedroom beach cottage with two docks and a boathouse with the rare vista offered by 447+/- feet of water frontage with sandy beach and bulkhead. Enjoy the stylish summer cottage as is while planning a dream waterfront build.

A rare opportunity to own an historic house with land that runs between Union and Jefferson Streets allowing for a south-facing light, room for a large garden and swimming pool is listed for sale. Included are permitted plans plans for a substantial addition on one of the largest residential parcels within this location of Sag Harbor Village. A three-quarter (.75 acre) site with mature landscaping and perimeter evergreens all makes for a securing a rare jewel in this convenient and central location and moments from the best of what Sag Harbor has to offer for one of the best lifestyle experiences on the East End.

Welcome to a breathtaking testament to luxury living at 1694 Millstone Rd, Sag Harbor. As you pull up the driveway, you'll immediately be struck by the grandeur of the home's cedar siding and stone exterior. The large windows allow natural light to flood the interior, showcasing the unparalleled craftsmanship and clean lines of this exceptional property. Situated on 1.85 acres, this home boasts a perfect blend of modern design and Italian/European elegance. The grand foyer welcomes you, leading to expansive living spaces adorned with the finest finishes and bespoke details. The gourmet kitchen is a chef's dream, featuring top-of-the-line Miele appliances, custom cabinetry that spans from floor to ceiling, and a large island perfect for culinary exploration. The dining area overlooks the meticulously landscaped grounds, creating the perfect setting for entertaining guests. The seven bedrooms offer a sense of comfort and luxury, each featuring an ensuite bathroom with radiant heated floors. The floor-to-ceiling windows drench the interiors with natural light, creating a seamless indoor-outdoor living experience. The estate's grounds are a true oasis, complete with a fully equipped pool house, gunite infinity pool that overlooks the private tennis court, and meticulously landscaped gardens. The lower level of the home offers a wellness center with a gym, spa, sauna, media room, and wine room - perfect for unwinding after a long day. This luxurious estate is the perfect home for the discerning buyer seeking the pinnacle of sophistication and modern living. With its unparalleled craftsmanship, elegant design, and stunning amenities, this property is a true masterpiece that will redefine luxury living in the Hamptons.

Welcome to your dream home, built by the legendary Farrell Building Company. Completed in 2023, this stunning new construction is situated on a tranquil and completely private 2.35-acre lot, boasting sweeping views of the 11th hole of Noyac Golf Course. Just moments away from Sag Harbor Village, this 8,500 square foot, 8-bedroom, 9-bathroom property offers water access through the Noyac Hills Estate Association, making it the perfect retreat for modern living. Step inside and be immediately greeted by the open floor plan, tri-tone kitchen, sweeping views of your backyard that are framed out by the golf course. The spacious living room, dining area, family room, laundry room, and first-floor primary bedroom provide all the comfort and convenience you could ask for. Upstairs, you'll find a secondary laundry area, 4 guest bedrooms with en suite bathrooms, and a luxurious primary bedroom featuring an en suite bathroom, roomy walk-in closet, and sliding doors to your private balcony offering breathtaking views. But the amenities don't stop there. This property also features a media room, bonus room, great room, and a gym, ensuring that you'll always have plenty of space to relax and entertain. Outside, the frame construction and wood siding give the property a timeless appeal. An attached 3-car garage, sunken tennis court, and heated gunite pool with a separate spa provide a private haven for relaxation and entertainment. Don't miss out on the opportunity to own this masterpiece of a home, built by one of the most renowned builders in the industry. With its luxurious amenities and prime location, this property truly has it all.

Welcome to a true masterpiece of luxury living in Sag Harbor, crafted by the esteemed Farrell Builders. This brand-new construction is the epitome of elegance, leisure, and natural beauty, perfectly positioned to deliver breathtaking panoramic views of the Noyac Golf Course. Nestled on an expansive 1.9-acre lot, this exquisite three-level home boasts 5 bedrooms, 6.5 bathrooms, 900 sq. ft. of unfinished space in the lower level, offering ample space and privacy for family and guests. The property features a two-car garage, a stunning heated gunite pool and spa, private tennis courts, a fully equipped home gym, and an indoor paddle board court. The property has deeded bay access through the Noyac Hills Estate Association, ideal for launching kayaks, paddles boards and more. The long, private driveway leads you to this pristine retreat, where country-club chic meets modern luxury. Step inside and be greeted by an impressive double-height entry foyer, where bright, beachy wide-plank floors set the tone for the rest of the home. Walls of windows and sliding glass doors seamlessly blend the indoor and outdoor living spaces, flooding the home with natural light and providing easy access to the poolside rear courtyard. The interior is a harmonious blend of designer aesthetics and functional open-concept living, perfect for both entertaining and everyday living. Custom accents such as tray ceilings, arched walkways, paneled walls, and clerestory windows add to the home's sophisticated charm. The great room and dining areas are graced with a cozy fireplace and a separate media room for ultimate relaxation. The elegant eat-in kitchen is a chef's dream, featuring Cuiffo cabinets, high-end stainless steel appliances, and a sleek, contemporary design. Adjacent to the dining area, you'll find a convenient rear patio, perfect for al fresco dining. Upstairs, the spacious primary suite is a true sanctuary, complete with a luxurious quartzite spa-like bath and a large private terrace overlooking the lush grounds. Two additional ensuite bedrooms offer comfort and privacy, including a first-floor junior primary suite with a luxe bath, walk-in closet, and private patio access. The lower level is designed for versatility and entertainment, featuring a fully equipped gym with a rejuvenating sauna, a lively playroom, and an additional ensuite bedroom with walkout stairs. Located in the heart of Sag Harbor, this home is just moments away from world-class golf, the Elizabeth Morton National Wildlife Preserve, and beautiful bay beaches. Enjoy the maritime charms and vibrant community of Noyac, making this property the ultimate Hamptons retreat. Don't miss this rare opportunity to own a piece of paradise in one of the most sought-after locations in the Hamptons. Schedule your private showing today and experience the pinnacle of luxury living.

Welcome to a breathtaking testament to luxury living at 1694 Millstone Rd, Sag Harbor. As you pull up the driveway, you'll immediately be struck by the grandeur of the home's cedar siding and stone exterior. The large windows allow natural light to flood the interior, showcasing the unparalleled craftsmanship and clean lines of this exceptional property. Situated on 1.85 acres, this home boasts a perfect blend of modern design and Italian/European elegance. The grand foyer welcomes you, leading to expansive living spaces adorned with the finest finishes and bespoke details. The gourmet kitchen is a chef's dream, featuring top-of-the-line Miele appliances, custom cabinetry that spans from floor to ceiling, and a large island perfect for culinary exploration. The dining area overlooks the meticulously landscaped grounds, creating the perfect setting for entertaining guests. The seven bedrooms offer a sense of comfort and luxury, each featuring an ensuite bathroom with radiant heated floors. The floor-to-ceiling windows drench the interiors with natural light, creating a seamless indoor-outdoor living experience. The estate's grounds are a true oasis, complete with a fully equipped pool house, gunite infinity pool that overlooks the private tennis court, and meticulously landscaped gardens. The lower level of the home offers a wellness center with a gym, spa, sauna, media room, and wine room - perfect for unwinding after a long day. This luxurious estate is the perfect home for the discerning buyer seeking the pinnacle of sophistication and modern living. With its unparalleled craftsmanship, elegant design, and stunning amenities, this property is a true masterpiece that will redefine luxury living in the Hamptons., Additional information: ExterioFeatures:Tennis